Quiltingboard Forums

Quiltingboard Forums (https://www.quiltingboard.com/)
-   Links and Resources (https://www.quiltingboard.com/links-resources-f4/)
-   -   Fee's for YouTube Video's please say it isn't the future trend!!!! (https://www.quiltingboard.com/links-resources-f4/fees-youtube-videos-please-say-isnt-future-trend-t218377.html)

onaemtnest 04-06-2013 04:51 AM

Fee's for YouTube Video's please say it isn't the future trend!!!!
 
Maybe I just crawled out from under a rock and this isn't new, but I just checked out a Carol Doak video, it was a short clip on YouTube. In order to see the entire video there is a toggle for renting the video for 72 hours @ $4.99.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oEOJQegt8HA

The C&T publishing is having a sale on one of her popular books and the site then sends you to the YouTube video that you can rent????

I sure hope this isn't a trend with YouTube instructional video's. I so enjoy Missouri Star Quilt tutorials and numerous other videos that have taught me techniques along the way.

I guess classes at popular websites that sell the classes for a one time fee with unlimited viewing are going to be real bargains.

PaperPrincess 04-06-2013 04:58 AM

This is the first I've heard of renting youtube videos, however, there have always been very short videos that direct you to a web site to purchase the full version. Seems weird at first, but I've bought videos for a lot more than $5 on a specific technique. Watched them once then never looked at them again. Maybe a smaller $ amount on a rental would be good. HAve to think about this.

onaemtnest 04-06-2013 05:07 AM


PaperPrincess~
I guess I'm a person who needs to review from time-to-time as I 'forget' from one quilt to another on certain techniques.

For instance there is a super slick (to me at least) binding video that an online store has. I seem to always forget the last part and need to 'refresh' my memory, how she folds and tucks :0) It may just be me at my age that I need refreshers and for that reason I'm glad that, so far, I haven't had to pay every month or so when I need to refresh a technique in this brain of mine.

It will be interesting to hear what other's think on this subject.

Cybrarian 04-06-2013 05:12 AM

Wow that could really add up! My Craftsy classes are even more appreciated. I also have a subscription to the Quilt Show with Alex Anderson and Ricky Timms which is a great bargain. Besides the great shows that I have learned so much about techniques, different types of quilting, and quilting world personalities, there are great classes and tutorials that are a part of the subscription. The last time I renewed I got an additional 6 months which made it an incredible bargain. I'm going to be focusing on things like this because you can go through a lot of money when you buy things piecemeal and it's easy to lose track of what you've paid for. That being said I have Carol Doak' s new Craftsy class on my wish list until I can purchase it. Love her!

Geri B 04-06-2013 05:36 AM

That might be an upcoming thing....nothing is free anymore...so sad. I even notice mags are slowly coming down in price..."good deals abound" on many subscription offers.

auntpiggylpn 04-06-2013 06:27 AM

Maybe it's just a Carol Doak thing. I sincerely doubt that Missouri Star Quilt Company will ever charge for their video tutorials

Weezy Rider 04-06-2013 06:47 AM

Google owns Youtube. There is talk of some type of overhaul for video streams, etc. But since Carol Doak and her kind are PUBLISHED authors and wish to profit from their expertise, expect Google to go along since Google also likes profits.

I'm not dissing these authors, they have a right to monetize. It's just an economic fact. Plus a charge and rent might deter the more innocent type of piracy. You download and give your friends a copy type of piracy that is.

This is one reason I won't use videos. I'll buy the book. Then the info is at my disposal at any time. I don't have to get up and turn on a player or the computer.

michelleoc 04-06-2013 06:53 AM

I hadn't heard anything about this, but I recently heard that they are trying to figure out how to charge us for sending emails...

Weezy Rider 04-06-2013 07:04 AM

As for MSC, if they are doing their own videos, and not posting anywhere but on their own site, that's their call. No one can make them charge if they don't want to. Craftsy seems to shoot a lot of theirs in a Denver Studio and host their own.

With the others that are being charged for - it might also be the publishing company that wants its cut.

I've heard about some of this - I own a Google phone, bought from Google. So stuff like this will appear on Android newsletters and forums.

DebraK 04-06-2013 08:56 AM

Where on earth did you hear that? You are already paying for emails by paying for broadband.

2blackcats 04-06-2013 11:57 AM


Originally Posted by auntpiggylpn (Post 5981773)
Maybe it's just a Carol Doak thing. I sincerely doubt that Missouri Star Quilt Company will ever charge for their video tutorials

I think Missouri Star Quilt Company makes more money selling their fabric and probably won't start charging - at least I hope not. But they did come out with a magazine you have to pay for.

NanaBeez 04-06-2013 09:48 PM

Carol Doak has a lot of free patterns on her web site. If you are just learning how to paper piece she is the best. I took a class from her years ago and she was nice and patient and a great teacher.

Yooper32 04-07-2013 03:29 AM

I think that it is more likely that you are sent to Utube to sample the CD that comes with that particular book, to see if that is what you want to purchase. In order to save bandwidth, if you want to watch the whole thing, which is probably lengthy, then they want compensation for that time.

labtechkty 04-07-2013 03:37 AM

I sincerely hope this isn't the trend. I'm a visual learner and need someone to show me step by step instructions before it sinks into this challenged brain of mine. That's why I like MSQC's quilting videos...

Cogito 04-07-2013 04:20 AM

Michelleoc, charging for emails has been proven to be a myth! That is not going to happen.

Caswews 04-07-2013 05:01 AM

interesting for sure ..

lclang 04-07-2013 05:31 AM

If there is a charge I won't be watching them. If they don't sell they will have to go to plan B.

pocoellie 04-07-2013 05:39 AM

I have heard that they were going to start charging for watching all U tube videos, but haven't heard when, I guess this is the start of it.

Tothill 04-07-2013 06:28 AM


Originally Posted by DebraK (Post 5982095)
Where on earth did you hear that? You are already paying for emails by paying for broadband.

Sending as well as receiving email uses considerable bandwidth which equals dollars. Companies that use newsletter services, Constant Contact, Mailchimp etc are paying an additional charge.

There is also a considerable cost to producing the emails, you can see which ones are more professional than others.

Facebook is now charging businesses to send updates to all the people who have liked their page.

It costs money to produce videos, I think we have been lucky to have free access to so many for so long. It also costs a lot of money to host videos, stream videos etc.

We often forget that as well as end users needing an internet connection, the video, needs to be uploaded to Youtube, stored there (storing and backing up data costs money), then there is the bandwidth to serve the video to you.

I am not surprised that people are looking to recoup some of their expenses.

quiltmom04 04-07-2013 07:10 AM

Since Carol Doak is in the business of making money from her books and classes, I doubt there would be much incentive to let you watch a free video of her technique on YouTube - or anywhere else. I would think YouTube will still have free videos, but perhaps business people are wising up and not giving their source of income away for free.

kat13 04-07-2013 07:37 AM


Originally Posted by labtechkty (Post 5983469)
I sincerely hope this isn't the trend. I'm a visual learner and need someone to show me step by step instructions before it sinks into this challenged brain of mine. That's why I like MSQC's quilting videos...

me too me too!! I think there wll always be the free videos, even sharon schamber has free ones but also has ones you have to pay for.

Lady Diana 04-07-2013 01:43 PM

This is a Carol Doak thing. Most retailers sell their goods at a 100% mark up. I know she makes at least a 500% mark up on her paper she sells for paper piecing. With that said, there is another issue that is a lot more important than the retailers charging for their wares, it is that the UN has made a move to gain control over the internet through the ITU International Telecommunications Union, which is part of the United Nations, which would bring in international governance of the internet.China, Russia and Saudi Arabia are strong supporters of the treaty. So far, the US has not signed the treaty. Then there is Google and their insidious way of getting information from the different apps and services they provide through the internet. I have not done an update on my phone due to Google's permission statement which says that if I update the Google related apps, I give them permission to access all information on my phone including photos, contacts...everything....just to upgrade programs that we used to pay for! It is always about control and money. I will get off my soap box now....we all should just stay informed and when we see our freedoms being infringed, contact your political representation.

Marysewfun 04-07-2013 04:00 PM

I love to watch the videos - as said you learn so much more by actually seeing something done than trying to follow along in a book - - and it is so much more invigorating to try the item they are doing. One thing I love about Jenny on Missouri Quilt videos - she is so natural - and if something isn't perfect (like a seam turned over while pressing) she just keeps on going and finds solutions for other little mishaps along the way. I just love watching her.

Marysewqfun

Texasjunebug 04-07-2013 07:28 PM


Originally Posted by Lady Diana (Post 5984942)
This is a Carol Doak thing. Most retailers sell their goods at a 100% mark up. I know she makes at least a 500% mark up on her paper she sells for paper piecing. With that said, there is another issue that is a lot more important than the retailers charging for their wares, it is that the UN has made a move to gain control over the internet through the ITU International Telecommunications Union, which is part of the United Nations, which would bring in international governance of the internet.China, Russia and Saudi Arabia are strong supporters of the treaty. So far, the US has not signed the treaty. Then there is Google and their insidious way of getting information from the different apps and services they provide through the internet. I have not done an update on my phone due to Google's permission statement which says that if I update the Google related apps, I give them permission to access all information on my phone including photos, contacts...everything....just to upgrade programs that we used to pay for! It is always about control and money. I will get off my soap box now....we all should just stay informed and when we see our freedoms being infringed, contact your political representation.

You are totally right about the issue. The UN also wants a "world citizen tax," to be paid to them of course. The controllers don't appear to be giving up easily as long as we do not expressly reject their efforts.

mjhaess 04-08-2013 07:51 AM

Never heard of paying but this may be the wave of the future...Everything seems to go that way after it catches on...Hope not...

BellaBoo 04-10-2013 08:01 AM

If I want something that cost money I pay for it. If I don't want something I won't pay for it. That applies for any internet content too. I'm not concerned either way about youtube.

nstitches4u 04-10-2013 05:38 PM

I think it is up to the person who makes the video. I don't think Jenny will charge for hers. At least I hope not.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:21 PM.