I used Oxy clean on #2 pencil marks that were 2 to 3 years old.
Welcome to the Quilting Board!

I used Oxy clean on #2 pencil marks that were 2 to 3 years old.
I use pencil to mark my quilts. Before I wash I use a Shout solid stain stick on all the marks, rubbing it in well.
I've had success in using this product called Sew Clean, found in some quilt stores. It also removes ballpoint inks.
Good luck with the stain. I have a quilt with pencil marks on it that have been there for ages. Don't know how to get them out so I am very interested in this answer. Good luck.
I had one, the dog uses it now..........................
Better to do something imperfectly, than nothing perfectly.
Done is better than perfect.
I find that if you iron over the pencil marks, it will be very hard to get them out, otherwise washing will do the trick
I use mechanical pencils frequently, and always erase the lines immediately after quilting the marked block. So far, so good. They come right off with the eraser. I do mark as I go, so the pencil lines do not stay on the fabric for a long time. I'm sorry this did not work for you this time.
LyndaWhen a dying man asked his pastor "How long does it take to die?" his pastor's heartfelt reply was "A lifetime." Live life to the fullest, but stop now and then to enjoy the sunset.
Glad it helped!