color catchers
10-21-2012, 01:59 PM
#11
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Kaua`i
Posts: 616
Consumer Reports may be correct about catchers not working in mixed clothes loads. I wouldn't know since I separate clothes into darks, lights, and wash anything new like a red sweatshirt separately. OTOH, if C.R. is saying catchers don't work at all, they are incorrect.
I wash like-colours together. I throw in a Shout catcher and, if it's drenched in colour, I send the load through another rinse leaving in the first catcher and adding a second one.
You can really tell the difference: the first catcher will pick up even more dye and the second catcher will be lighter. Repeat until the newest catcher is white or pale.
The Shout Colour Catchers work! I rarely need to do a third rinse.
FYI, I wash the like-colour fabrics just the way I expect the quilt to end up being washed: warm wash, cold rinse with Tide Free. I put the catcher in at the beginning of the wash cycle.
Shout is the only brand I've tried. I stock up when they are on sale.
I wash like-colours together. I throw in a Shout catcher and, if it's drenched in colour, I send the load through another rinse leaving in the first catcher and adding a second one.
You can really tell the difference: the first catcher will pick up even more dye and the second catcher will be lighter. Repeat until the newest catcher is white or pale.
The Shout Colour Catchers work! I rarely need to do a third rinse.
FYI, I wash the like-colour fabrics just the way I expect the quilt to end up being washed: warm wash, cold rinse with Tide Free. I put the catcher in at the beginning of the wash cycle.
Shout is the only brand I've tried. I stock up when they are on sale.
Originally Posted by danade
If you use a color catcher, how do you tell if it has worked enough so you won't have any more unacceptable bleeding--even if it seems to have gathered up all the bleeding from fabric, don't you have to go through a second wash with a new color catcher to see if the excess dye is really gone? I'm thinking especially of batiks.
Here's a resource about color catchers:
consumerreports.com/.....color catchers
They tested both the Shout and the Carbona color catchers and their opinion was that they didn't work as claimed. I'm confused.
Dana
Here's a resource about color catchers:
consumerreports.com/.....color catchers
They tested both the Shout and the Carbona color catchers and their opinion was that they didn't work as claimed. I'm confused.
Dana
Last edited by HouseDragon; 10-21-2012 at 02:09 PM.
10-21-2012, 02:03 PM
#12
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2012
Posts: 764
oh please please please let colour catchers work. i am almost finished this red white and blue quilt and having inherited the fabrics, prewashed them and used them, i am still very nervous about the bleeding. i had a friend pick up some colour catchers for me in the states.
(there is already a spot where something has bled on this quilt thanks to a leaky iron. i am sure it's going to run like mad....)
aileen
(there is already a spot where something has bled on this quilt thanks to a leaky iron. i am sure it's going to run like mad....)
aileen
10-21-2012, 02:11 PM
#13
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Long Island
Posts: 798
Yes my red sheets still blead after so may washes. They are not the only sheets I have but I like them the most because they are a good quality set we got when we got married. The thing is I did not know they blead since it is a large set and fills the machine so they are always washed by themselves until I tossed in a color catcher by habit. Boy was I surprised.
About chemicals, color catchers are as benign as they get. When I get back home and to my own computer I will post a link to DIY color catchers.
About chemicals, color catchers are as benign as they get. When I get back home and to my own computer I will post a link to DIY color catchers.
10-21-2012, 02:47 PM
#14
Power Poster
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: Michigan
Posts: 11,276
One thing to watch out for is that you are not supposed to use color catchers in a front loader. Not enough water. I had been using them in my old top loader machine. When I got my new front loader, I did a load with a color catcher as usual. The color catcher caught the color (say that fast 3 times) but when I took the load out, the color catcher was plastered against a light colored garment and had deposited the color onto it. I'm guessing during the spin cycle. Anyway, if you read the box they say not to use them in a top loader. Earlier this year I started using Retayne. An inexpensive and effective remedy.
10-21-2012, 03:00 PM
#15
Super Member
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Southwest Kansas
Posts: 4,820
Originally Posted by ghostrider
The above link is bad, Try this instead.
http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/m...view/index.htm
I don't use color catchers; waste of money as far as I'm concerned, invented so people could wash all their colors together and not bother separating them. I'm not in that much of a hurry with regular laundry and I prewash all quilting fabrics (like colors together and never with regular laundry) until any excess dyes are gone. If they still bleed after two washes, they get treated with Retayne...end of problem.
I'm very surprised to hear Tashana's red sheets are still bleeding after being washed twice a week every week for 10 years! That has to be some kind of record.
Vinegar has NO effect on today's dyes. It will NOT set colors used to dye cotton. Salt will not do anything either.
http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/m...view/index.htm
I don't use color catchers; waste of money as far as I'm concerned, invented so people could wash all their colors together and not bother separating them. I'm not in that much of a hurry with regular laundry and I prewash all quilting fabrics (like colors together and never with regular laundry) until any excess dyes are gone. If they still bleed after two washes, they get treated with Retayne...end of problem.
I'm very surprised to hear Tashana's red sheets are still bleeding after being washed twice a week every week for 10 years! That has to be some kind of record.
Vinegar has NO effect on today's dyes. It will NOT set colors used to dye cotton. Salt will not do anything either.
The problem fabric is the one that picks the dye up!
10-21-2012, 03:15 PM
#16
Super Member
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 4,688
Originally Posted by HouseDragon
Consumer Reports may be correct about catchers not working in mixed clothes loads. I wouldn't know since I separate clothes into darks, lights, and wash anything new like a red sweatshirt separately. OTOH, if C.R. is saying catchers don't work at all, they are incorrect.
I wash like-colours together. I throw in a Shout catcher and, if it's drenched in colour, I send the load through another rinse leaving in the first catcher and adding a second one.
You can really tell the difference: the first catcher will pick up even more dye and the second catcher will be lighter. Repeat until the newest catcher is white or pale.
The Shout Colour Catchers work! I rarely need to do a third rinse.
I wash like-colours together. I throw in a Shout catcher and, if it's drenched in colour, I send the load through another rinse leaving in the first catcher and adding a second one.
You can really tell the difference: the first catcher will pick up even more dye and the second catcher will be lighter. Repeat until the newest catcher is white or pale.
The Shout Colour Catchers work! I rarely need to do a third rinse.
I seldom need a third wash for bleeding fabrics using no color catcher at all. It's the washing that gets rid of the excess dyes, not the color catchers. All they do is show you there's loose dye in the water...and merely looking at the water or adding a white wash cloth to the load will tell you that much.
You'd be far better off using Synthrapol, a product that chemically suspends loose dyes in the wash water until they are drained out of the machine, than something that claims to "trap loose dyes and prevent color runs", a dye magnet if you will.
Retayne, by the way, is not intended for use with mixed colors. It's for use on uncut fabrics, before they get made into a quilt. It will set loose dyes on any fabric in the wash load, not at all what you want for a finished quilt or a mixed load of wash.
10-22-2012, 04:56 PM
#18
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2012
Location: Killeen, Texas
Posts: 329
Ghostrider, thanks for commenting upon the vinegar and salt methods. We can never assume that the status quo will always be the same for fabric manufacturing. I have great luck with color catchers with regular laundry...never had a mishap...on occasion I may only have several colored items in with lighter fabrics. Most of the time I have enough laundry to have enough for a white, color and dark load. However, for today's quilting fabrics I tend to lean towards Retayne for washing before cutting and piecing and Synthrapol for the post-completion wash.
Originally Posted by ghostrider
The above link is bad, Try this instead.
http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/m...view/index.htm
I don't use color catchers; waste of money as far as I'm concerned, invented so people could wash all their colors together and not bother separating them. I'm not in that much of a hurry with regular laundry and I prewash all quilting fabrics (like colors together and never with regular laundry) until any excess dyes are gone. If they still bleed after two washes, they get treated with Retayne...end of problem.
I'm very surprised to hear Tashana's red sheets are still bleeding after being washed twice a week every week for 10 years! That has to be some kind of record.
Vinegar has NO effect on today's dyes. It will NOT set colors used to dye cotton. Salt will not do anything either.
http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/m...view/index.htm
I don't use color catchers; waste of money as far as I'm concerned, invented so people could wash all their colors together and not bother separating them. I'm not in that much of a hurry with regular laundry and I prewash all quilting fabrics (like colors together and never with regular laundry) until any excess dyes are gone. If they still bleed after two washes, they get treated with Retayne...end of problem.
I'm very surprised to hear Tashana's red sheets are still bleeding after being washed twice a week every week for 10 years! That has to be some kind of record.
Vinegar has NO effect on today's dyes. It will NOT set colors used to dye cotton. Salt will not do anything either.
10-23-2012, 05:58 AM
#19
Super Member
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: soCal
Posts: 1,495
I had quilts for Granddaughters with a red backing that was rubbing off on my white sewing machine - yikes!! I did some research and bought Color Catchers - they caught the red colour and it did not transfere to the white, red and green fronts. I have been using them ever since for all quilts. You can safety pin the sheet so that it doesn't get lost or end up on another article in the washer. These sheets are part of my quilting tools since I found them!
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
