Thread: Which Costco iron? Rowenta or Sunbeam

I guess I've been burned too many times by the "don't make em like they used to" flame, so I now buy everything at Costco where I can return it if it breaks in a year!

I, of course, relinquished my old reliable Black and Decker iron to a remodeling project and now it's ruined (SOB!) I figured it would be fun to get a new iron, but I'm rethinking that idea based on reviews I've read, so I'm back to buying at Costco.

So my two (Costco) choices of irons are:
Rowenta SteamPower (which appears to be a Costco-specific Pro Master) ~$70
Sunbeam Turbo Steam Master Pro ~$30.

I actually bought the Rowenta, but it's huge, heavy, and puts out more steam than I like (cough-cough). I also don't think it gets very hot. I think it would be nice for clothing, but for quilting, not so much.

I'd go get the Sunbeam, but I want to make sure I'm not going to be returning it right away because it's extraordinarily sub-par or something.

So question: For quilting!!!!

Do you own either of these irons?
Does the weight and steam of the Rowenta pay off once a person gets used to it?
Is the Sunbeam a good iron?

Any other considerations welcome.

Thank you in advance!

I used a Sunbeam for awhile and only replaced it because it got dropped too many times.

I have a Rowenta and love it because it produces lots of steam. But it is heavy. Some complain of leaking but I have had mine over a year now and don't have any problems, but I do the self cleaning purge every week to remove minerals, etc.

I will never buy a Rowenta again, I have had two and both have leaked. I would go with the Sunbeam.

I have had two Rowenta's first one lasted 20 years, I am on the second one now. I love it. Yes it is heavy, and makes lots of steam. I never clean it and it just keeps going.

I't has been a year or so since my experience, but will tell you that I bought the Sunbeam iron from Costco - I smelled something burning and saw that the plastic housing had a hole burned right through it. I returned it, tried another one hoping that it was just a faulty unit - but almost the same thing happened with the new one. After that, I decided to move on to something else.