Quiltingboard Forums

Quiltingboard Forums (https://www.quiltingboard.com/)
-   Main (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/)
-   -   Hand Quilting or Machine Quilting or Both? (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/hand-quilting-machine-quilting-both-t37203.html)

DannyValentine 02-17-2010 09:37 AM

Yesterday I went into the quilt shop here in Bossier and I was talking to a lady who worked there. She was trying to get me to buy a sewing machine and she said machine sewing is so much better and faster than handquilting and she said once you start machine sewing you'll never go back to hand sewing again. So my question is what works best for you? Me personally, I like hand quilting. I like having my hands busy. I'm like my husband. I'm always fidgeting and need my hands busy.

Lisa_wanna_b_quilter 02-17-2010 09:40 AM

Sewing machines are faster. That doesn't make them "better". It's a personal preference. Whatever makes you happy.

I avoid hand sewing at all costs, but I do hand embroidery and would never consider an embroidery machine.

LoisN 02-17-2010 09:42 AM

I have just started machine quilting and I love it. I found that hand-quilting was difficult for me because I couldn't manage a quilt on a big quilting frame. I never could get my hand in the right position. Felt like I was standing on my head to reach different angles. Well, I took the sampler quilt out of that frame, machine quilted the sashing and hand-quilted the individual blocks. Loved doing it that way. It worked better for me than either all machine quilting or all hand-quilting.

Up North 02-17-2010 09:52 AM

I have not been very successful at machine quilting. I prefer the look of hand quilting and enjoy doing it. I tried the large frame and gave up. I couldn't reach far enough and so a lap frame or my small oval floor frame work best for me. And they are portable. I can move the small floor frame from room to room and can quilt on trips with my lap frame.

littlehud 02-17-2010 11:23 AM

My hands don't like hand sewing so I machine quilt but I drool over hand quilted quilts. I do what I am able to do.

Marjpf 02-17-2010 11:27 AM

It really depends on the final look I want to achieve and my mood. I think that hand quilting has a softer look to it. If I don't have any other TV time projects going, I will hand quilt something. If I am in a hurry or want a more detailed design, I machine quilt.

jljquilter 02-17-2010 11:37 AM

I hand quilt because I don't have a machine that will quilt. My machine is 34 years old and the feed dogs won't drop. I use either a hoop or a q-snap frame. I can quilt any size quilts with them. These also allow me to take them with me in the car. Husband drives and I quilt.

mpspeedy 02-17-2010 12:20 PM

Since I have been handquilting for 40 years I am kind of partial. I do machine quilt Linus quilts and ones I make for small children. Anything larger than a twin bed size is to much for me to handle with my machine. I have a full size Bernina. The problem is my arms, back and neck. I have an autoimmune disease that makes my muscles weak. Wrestling that big quilt in order to get it under my machine is too much for me. When I go to sew the binding on a big quilt I have finished my husband either helps me but holding up the weight for me or I set up several folding tables around my machine to hold the weight.

retired teacher 02-17-2010 12:30 PM

I machine qquilt during the day and then do hand work at nights. The only hand made quilt though is the Grandmothers flower Garden. I need to get that out and get going on it again
I do both hand quilting or machine quilting when putting the 3 layers together. Sometimes send them out to be quilted

renee765 02-17-2010 12:35 PM

I think either hand or machine quilting is just fine if that is what the quilter wants to do. I like to hand quilt, so that is my preference - but only because I enjoy doing it. Sometimes the quilt will tell you what it wants. I tried hand quilting on my current project three different ways and didn't like any of it. The machine quilting was just what it needed. Just listen to your quilt and do what pleases you. It will be great!

k3n 02-17-2010 12:41 PM

I only hand sewed (pieced and quilted) for years, now I machine as well. It's not 'better' or worse for that matter but it is faster. Hand sewing in the evening watching TV - quilting, EPP or embroidery of crazy blocks I find very relaxing. Here in France, there is a prejudice against machine work, like it's cheating in some way. If you go to quilt shows, you see ppl turn away in disgust from quilts annotated as machine pieced or quilted. But using a machine is an art in itself I think, especially FMQ which is bloomin difficult! I say both ways have equal value and ya boo sucks to those who say mean things about one or the other!

cjaye44 02-17-2010 03:21 PM

I like to machine piece and prefer to hand quilt in a frame. I have started machine quilting the Downy quilts but it's very basic. Anything larger than twin is awkward for me. I'm totally in awe tho of work I've seen done by LA quilters. It's a real art form.

sewingladydi 02-17-2010 03:30 PM

I love to hand quilt in a small lap hoop, but it is very time consuming so for charity quilts (like quilts for kids) or table toppers, I straight line machine quilt.

For a bed quilt, I sometimes do both hand and machine. My first quilt was an Irish chain (when I discovered how annoying it is to hand quilt across all those seams)I did some on machine and some hand quilting.

I want to do free motion machine-am taking a class soon

zz-pd 02-17-2010 03:31 PM

Its what ever makes you happy :)

QuiltMania 02-17-2010 05:42 PM

I do both. Depends on what quilt I'm doing.

MadQuilter 02-17-2010 05:54 PM

If I want ANYTHING to get DONE, I have to do it by machine. I think it is personal preference. Not something to compete.

brushandthimble 02-17-2010 07:15 PM

I do have a couple of quilts and a wall hanging I hand quilted. Pain made me stop hand quilting, and just gave my large floor hoop away. I have done queen and one king on my DM machine, now I have the HQ16 and love it. I do love the look of hand quilting and wish I could still do some.

lisalovesquilting 02-18-2010 03:50 AM


Originally Posted by jljquilter
I hand quilt because I don't have a machine that will quilt. My machine is 34 years old and the feed dogs won't drop. I use either a hoop or a q-snap frame. I can quilt any size quilts with them. These also allow me to take them with me in the car. Husband drives and I quilt.

Hi jlj, You can cover your feed dogs by taping a business card over them. Or you can machine quilt with stitch in the ditch or echo or gentle curves. Hope this helps if you do want to machine quilt.

ckcowl 02-18-2010 04:52 AM

I do alot of hand work because i work in the 'private-duty' home health care and have lots of time to be busy with not much to do, so I sew...when i'm home i use my machine ALOT but in the evenings if i want to sit with dh and watch tv the hand work comes back out...i really enjoy both, most of my hand work was applique and embroidery but recently started hand piecing and am lovin' it! the precision is great, much easier to achieve than with the machine and i am really enjoying the process...i probably hand work 65-70% machine sew the other 30-35%

rndelling 02-18-2010 07:38 AM

Machine quilting is definitely faster but that doesn't always mean better. I just don't enjoy machine quilting. I do it for wallhangings and sometimes baby quilts but it just isn't my thing. I love to hand quilt. It's all personal preference.
Do what you enjoy the most. That's what quilting is all about.

Boston1954 02-18-2010 07:40 AM

I like hand quilting simply because it is by hand. I feel the quilt is more ME when I am done. Hope that makes sense.

Joanieu 02-18-2010 09:28 AM

I piece by machine, but hand quilt using a lap hoop, pc snap frame or without a frame/hoop. I love doing it that way personally. It is how you feel and enjoy. I am scared to death to try machine quilting, plus I just enjoy the hand motion. On my next quilt I am thinking of going back to hand piecing - this last one I pieced by machine just really made me mad - Will post pictures when I get it sandwiched and quilted -maybe a year from now. :) Just do what you like to do and just make it fun and not hard work.

Smitty47 02-18-2010 09:58 AM

I started in quilting a few years ago, machine quilting midarm to help my wife finish some of the many projects and tops she gad piled up. I had gone to a quilt show and was really impressed with the artful peices. Being a retired finish carpenter, I thought Id give it a try and have really enjoyed it. Have tried the hand quilting and hand bindings to appreciate what many enjoy doing, but find it far too time consuming when you have so many projects and I like seeing thing DONE. I am getting a lot of requests to finish tops and and machine binding, small baby quilts etc so they can give them to family and friends while their still at the age they can be of use. My hats off to those of you who choose to hand quilt and I appreciate the endlees hours and dedication required to you put in on your quilts. I have to prduce 3 to 4 quilt a week so I find my machine is my preferrence.

weezie 02-18-2010 11:20 AM

I have several projects going at once. I do both hand quilting and machine quilting. Some people hate one or the other, but it's nice and it's handy if you like to do both. Hand quilting is much slower, but I'm better at it than I am at machine quilting. Also, there's nothing that says you can't do both hand and machine quilting on the same quilt.

Deecee 02-18-2010 02:23 PM

I enjoy both.
If I am sewing "home alone" I use the machine in my sewing room. When hubby is home of an evening I hand sew in the loungeroom watching TV with him.

I find hand sewing (whether it be quilting, hand applique or whatever) relaxing of an evening but I get more done on the machine during the day.

grammypatty7 02-18-2010 02:40 PM


Originally Posted by DannyValentine
Yesterday I went into the quilt shop here in Bossier and I was talking to a lady who worked there. She was trying to get me to buy a sewing machine and she said machine sewing is so much better and faster than handquilting and she said once you start machine sewing you'll never go back to hand sewing again. So my question is what works best for you? Me personally, I like hand quilting. I like having my hands busy. I'm like my husband. I'm always fidgeting and need my hands busy.

I'm a hand quilter by preference and thoroughly enjoy doing it and fine it relaxing and theraputic but I am trying to learn to machine quilt because several of my friends in my retirement community have arthritis and can no longer hand quilt or sew anything by hand. As you get older you have to look at things differently and since I love quilting so much have decided that it would be wise for me to learn machine quilting now so that should the time come where I couldn't hand quilt, I could still be a quilter. Those ladies do miss hand quilting but said they would really miss quilting more so they machine quilt and do beautiful and awesome work. Aren't we lucky to live in a time where we have options like that.

I'd say follow your personal preferences but open your mind to other possibilities in the process. I'm also learning different methods of quilt as you go as well, just in case and hopefully I'll be able to continue enjoying quilting for many more years in one form or the other.

grandma Janice 02-18-2010 06:36 PM

I have always hand pieced and hand quilt. since the old hands are not as nimble as they use to be, I have started machine piecing but there are some patterns that I can only hand piece if I want them to go together right. I love to hand quilt. don't have a quilting machine. not sure I would like it.

sandpat 02-18-2010 06:56 PM

I say either one you would like and/or both! I do both depending on what look I want as the end result. One is not easier than the other to me...machine is maybe...."maybe" faster, again depending on what you are trying to accomplish. I enjoy both though.

foxxigrani 02-19-2010 06:36 AM

I do both on the same quilt. I may hand quilt some parts and machine others, all depends on how I feel and what the quilt says. I always thought that was funny what the quilt says and had never had one talk to me until recently. I had a quilt in the frame ready to hand quilt and for some reason could not get my mind around the hand quilting on this one. I am not a fancy quilter in either hand or machine, usually just do echo hand and either sitd or just a diagional. Very simple, but this quilt said no hand. Go figure. I know I am getting a little old, but I don't hear voices YET. lol. Its whatever you prefer, its your quilt and I do like both in a quilt.
Since I am so simple minded that is.. Opps did I say that outloud?

Rita

Tippy 02-19-2010 07:03 AM

I did nothing but hand work for years.. I have actually had other "experienced quilters" stand in a shop and argue with me that I had machine pieced a quilt. Then I was told that I did not know how to quilt...despite the piece laying there with my needle still attached, because I do a stab stitch or needlepoint quilting as some have called it. Recently I learned to use a longarm and have started machine piecing and quilting. I think both have merits.. depending on the pattern I can sometimes hand piece faster than I machine piece.. some blocks that I love to hand piece I wouldn't even attempt on the machine. Other quilts go way faster on machine. as far as how long they last, I strongly disagree with that lady. Just look in the museums.
Hand stitching can last just as well as machine.depends on the materials and the workmanship.

Sharon - NC 02-19-2010 07:35 AM

I hand pieced and hand quilted (without a hoop or frame) the quilt in my avatar. I thoroughly enjoyed it but it took a very long time. I'm now learning to machine piece and finished my first project, a wall hanging. I want to machine piece and then do a combo of machine SID and hand quilting some lap-sized quilts for chemo patients. I chose to do them by machine because otherwise I'd only finish one every couple of months and wouldn't be able to give many away.

lynmh 02-19-2010 08:45 AM

Glad to see someone else does both. I too like to hand quilt, but some of it I do enjoy machine quilting. Since I dont plan on entering anything in shows I see no reason to do both.
Yes machine quilting and sewing is faster..I do not like to hand piece but I LOVE applique and needle turn is all I do. So it is totally your choice.

lyn

Emily Brown 02-19-2010 01:32 PM

Hi. To me it would depend on what type block it is, what the quilt is going to be used for, lots of use , wall hanging etc. Dont give up on either one. You can enjoy both. Emily Adair :-)

Olivia's Grammy 02-19-2010 01:47 PM

I started by hand quilting. I have hooks in my ceiling where my frame hung. My DH had his cousin make my frames. I did several that way. Now I have a HQ16 and machine quilt. I still do hand work in the evenings. I like to do redwork.

Jingle 02-19-2010 02:59 PM

I hand quilted 24 quilts before machine quilting became popular and items to do it were available. I have machine quilted 36 in a lot less time. At 64 years old, I just want to make as many quilts as I can. I was never good at hand quilting so I figure machine quilting is just as good. To each their own. Do whatever makes you happy...

sylvia77 02-19-2010 05:12 PM

I quilt entirely by machine. I have arthritis in my hands so I never even learned how to hand quilt and I don't have the time. I love the look of hand quilting but I have to quilt using my machine. It's not always easy but you do what you got to do.

jljquilter 02-19-2010 06:28 PM

I agree. You do with what you have. People worry about hand quilting that the stitches won't be small enough. Most people are just amazed at the quilt either hand or machine quilted. It takes ability and skill to do either.

grammypatty7 02-19-2010 06:42 PM


Originally Posted by foxxigrani
I do both on the same quilt. I may hand quilt some parts and machine others, all depends on how I feel and what the quilt says. I always thought that was funny what the quilt says and had never had one talk to me until recently. I had a quilt in the frame ready to hand quilt and for some reason could not get my mind around the hand quilting on this one. I am not a fancy quilter in either hand or machine, usually just do echo hand and either sitd or just a diagional. Very simple, but this quilt said no hand. Go figure. I know I am getting a little old, but I don't hear voices YET. lol. Its whatever you prefer, its your quilt and I do like both in a quilt.
Since I am so simple minded that is.. Opps did I say that outloud?

Rita

You're listening to the quilt and following your instincts - me too. Many won't understand that but I sure do.

grammypatty7 02-19-2010 06:46 PM


Originally Posted by Tippy
I did nothing but hand work for years.. I have actually had other "experienced quilters" stand in a shop and argue with me that I had machine pieced a quilt. Then I was told that I did not know how to quilt...despite the piece laying there with my needle still attached, because I do a stab stitch or needlepoint quilting as some have called it. Recently I learned to use a longarm and have started machine piecing and quilting. I think both have merits.. depending on the pattern I can sometimes hand piece faster than I machine piece.. some blocks that I love to hand piece I wouldn't even attempt on the machine. Other quilts go way faster on machine. as far as how long they last, I strongly disagree with that lady. Just look in the museums.
Hand stitching can last just as well as machine.depends on the materials and the workmanship.

I have 25 years plus of quilts in hard daily use and the few quilts that have needed repair was due to getting caught when drug around the house or fabric wear - my hand quilting has held up amazingly well and is beautiful. My first two quilts that I hand pieced did NOT fare that well as I ended up having to do a lot of repair of the piecing and vowed never again so I now machine piece and hand quilt. I'm in the process of beginning to experiment with some machine and some hand quilting to see how that goes.

Oklahoma Suzie 02-20-2010 05:17 AM

It's what you like. I'm not into machine quilting yet, but do want to learn to do it.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:48 AM.