Scallops say 'Country' to me, and this quilt seems more modern. I'd skip it on this one unless you are going to embroider or applique motifs in the border.

If you wanted scallops, you should check out Eddie's tutorial:

http://www.quiltingboard.com/t-25080-1.htm

I think his method would work well with your sketch. Note - his pics start on pg 3, but the directions start at the beginning. If you followed the contour of the rings with the scallops, it would probably look pretty good.

It took a little Photoshopping, but I put a scalloped border on the design to give a better idea on what it would look like. I put it on a black background so it would show up better. And I do realize the scallops are a tad bit too deep (I did this kind of quick), but again this is just to give a better idea on what it would look like with scallops.

[IMG]http://i132.photobucket.com/albums/q...NAGIRLcopy.jpg[/IMG]

I think its looks awesome !!!

Sorry, I have to agree with IrishRose.

I love the scalloped border, it balances the block pattern very nicely.

Go for it!

I did the Ribbon Puzzle block from quilterscache.com:
http://www.quilterscache.com/R/RibbonPuzzleBlock.html
This was only the 3rd large quilt I had made.....almost 5 years ago now.

The pattern is a bit different from yours as they ribbons are not made from individual blocks, but I did scallop the edges (and did a cross hatch quilting on the border).

i'd do points on the edge before scallops

I find scallops to be very feminine. Since this is for a young girl I believe the scallops would be fine. Plus it's another skill you add to your repertoire!

I like the scallops. I agree the ones on your design are too deep. It would be awsome with gentle scallops. Let us see it when done. I really like lovespaper's quilt. I have used many patterns from Quilters Cache.
Sue