My votes is for number 2. It absolutely pops, and looks so 3 dimensional, and then my next choice is number 4 :)

IMHO I would go with #4. I like the extra space around the compass. #1 is nice but I lose the compass a bit in the blue.

I like all of them but #4 is my choice.

number 4 is my choice..i had to look twice when i first looked at them as it looked like your mariners compass was on a wooden parquetry floor but then i realised it was fabric..

Love #1 the best but #4 would be my 2nd choice. Beautiful quilt.

Oh my gosh they all are pretty......but if I had to choose it would be the second one...

#4

Number 1 please....it is really a beauty! I love it!

#1

I like them all! But if I had to choose, I'd go with the first or last one.