I think someone had made little stuffed mice out of felt with leather shoe laces for tails.
Matchbook needle holders.
A cocoa kit - a package of instant cocoa, some marshmallows, a candy cane - with or without a mug.
Bottled water, pop/soda, cookies - but that may be elsewhere at the sale.
Card holders or baskets.
Christmas card "tote" - place for addresses, stamps, cards, etc.
Christmas stockings. Mini ones to use as tree decorations.