Sounds like there are a few good options. I think I'm tending towards the Quilter's Dream, mainly due to no shrinkage since it will be a more modern quilt and I'd prefer that look. I haven't used poly since I started quilting many years ago and used a less than the best poly batting. I guess that is my hesitance toward poly, but I suspect the quality of the QD is much better than what I experienced many years ago. I appreciate all the input!