zozee

The second one, definitely! It really showcases the fabrics, looks balanced, and to my eye--looks complete. The first one left me wanting a third piece. The second one gave me a settled feeling.

SusieQOH

I like both so of course I'm no help!
I have that pattern but haven't done it yet.

illinois

Even as they are, I prefer the symmetry of the second one as it shows off the fabric rather than the design. Final decision might be the use you will have for it. Do you have space for the longer one? Do you intend to put something in the center of the design (flowers, candle or such)? If you intend to put something there, probably #2 would be best but, if you have 2 things, #1.

MarionsQuilts

I love the second one. I've done a number of these in both styles, and once they are all done, I've always preferred the second layout - a much more finished look. Beautiful fabric!

cindyb

So where have I been? I don't remember seeing this before. Can anyone tell me where to get this pattern.

quilterpurpledog

Both are very nice so it is hard to choose. The fabric choice is great. I have made this pattern several times and it is always dramatic. Don't forget to show us the finished project.

kittenquilts

Either way would be great! Love them both.

Karamarie

Nice, my favorite is 2.

JanieH

Love both of them but I like the fact that the second one has a "designated" space for an arrangement or other decoration.

DJ

Tough decision! Both are fantastic.