Quiltingboard Forums

Quiltingboard Forums (https://www.quiltingboard.com/)
-   General Chit-Chat (non-quilting talk) (https://www.quiltingboard.com/general-chit-chat-non-quilting-talk-f7/)
-   -   Cookie Table at weddings? (https://www.quiltingboard.com/general-chit-chat-non-quilting-talk-f7/cookie-table-weddings-t209077.html)

tulip43 12-25-2012 10:30 AM

never heard of this and we have catered at many weddings. I think this is a great idea.

meanmom 12-25-2012 11:19 AM

I have never heard of a cookie table at a wedding but it sounds yummy. Several of the nieces and nephews in my family and my daughter don't really like cake. SO they had a small wedding cake for them and served cheesecakes to the guests. I made them all. Some of the weddings I made several different kinds of cheesecakes. Everyone liked it. It was somthing different.

dc989 12-25-2012 12:09 PM

I have never heard of this tradition on the west coast, but cupcake trees in lieu of a huge wedding cake have become popular. I think that is a great idea. Have you ever been "HONORED" with the job of cake cutter? That is a horrid job. Thankfully it is usually reserved for the younger gals.

squires1042 12-25-2012 12:11 PM

When my niece was married in Erie PA a few years ago they had a full sit down meal and then the cookie table. Her brother who was married in Pittsburgh did not have the cookie table. This was new to me, hadn't seen it before. I know my sil, mil and aunts on both sides spent weeks baking and freezing cookies for it.

quilty 69 12-25-2012 01:07 PM

I'm from same area and it wouldn't be a reception without the cookie table.

kathdavis 12-25-2012 01:11 PM


Originally Posted by sarahelloyd (Post 5738690)
I live in Great Britain, and have never heard of such a thing although it is fascinating. Are the cookies special shapes or colours or does anything go? We usually have a tiered cake although cupcakes are starting to make an appearance too. Also the idea of taking food home with you is really strange to us, what you don't eat you just leave, it would be so much better for it to be taken home and shared out.

Usually they are Italian cookies like biscotti, chocolate tattoos, sesame seed, tea balls, Hello Dollies, etc. most tables have at least 15-20 different types.

JoanneS 12-25-2012 03:28 PM

I live in CT, grew up in CA, have relatives in SD and ND (but haven't gone to weddings there). This is the first I've ever heard of a cookie table - but I think it's a wonderful idea. I wouldn't be surprised if they do it in the Dakotas, because all my relatives and friends there are superb cookie makers!

karate lady 12-25-2012 04:45 PM


Originally Posted by grma33 (Post 5736349)
never heard of this either.but great custom
my dd just got married in florida this past oct and she already had 2 boys so we had a sundae bar.every topping you could imangine
everyone loved it!
Gale

My grand son had the sundae bar at his wedding in Calif. Great success. I didn't even miss cake.... smile.

alfosa421 12-25-2012 05:21 PM

Definitely a cookie table but watch that the wait staff doesn't steal all the lady locks!!!

cherrio 12-25-2012 05:32 PM


Originally Posted by quilty 69 (Post 5740023)
I'm from same area and it wouldn't be a reception without the cookie table.

I also live in Niles!! small world huh? I live near the High School

cherrio 12-25-2012 05:55 PM

and yes, we have boxes for cake but I see alot of guests just put things on paper plates toss a napkin over it and home it goes! (not at my daughter's wedding-there were no paper plates to be found lol) Some weddings are a bit more casual and others are held in more formal settings. doesn't matter here-cookies are the expected.

Clothes pins, mini cupcakes with cream cheese centers, tiny kolochi, a strawberry cookie-my fave, always chocolate chips for the kids, lemon bars, peanut butter with hershey kisses on top cream cheese dainties, different flavored pitzels, chocolate dipped strawberries and chocolate dipped pretzels , and there are more that the aunts and cousins make; sprinkle in some good chocolate candies. I wish I could post pics because even tho I'm not a big cookie eater-it always looks so tempting! sugar cookies in the shape of wedding bells and decorated in the wedding colors are so popular. snow balls and chocolate crinkles are always my sisters contribution. and since the last daughter was married in November (6 years ago) we made extras for that Christmas at the same time since many cookies freeze well.
so, the majority of responders weren't familiar with this custom. that's ok, I have 2 more to wed yet so keep the customs coming! love the sharing and experience here.

rorostat 12-25-2012 06:21 PM

cookie table at weddings
 
I am from NE Ohio and have been told that this is a regional tradition. All the weddings here have them and some are now doing "Candy" bars...jars of candies and little plastic bags to take them home in.

tubroh730 12-25-2012 07:05 PM

Cookie Tables not new to me
 
4 Attachment(s)
Yes, this is a small world. I am originally from Niles, OH and still live in NE Ohio.

When my son and DIL were planning their wedding a few years ago, I was curious about the history of the cookie table. To me, it was an expected part of the menu. I learned that decades long ago (circa Depression), the families might not be able to afford a wedding cake, so family members and friends baked cookies and brought them for the happy couple. This seemed to originate with ethnic ceremonies, but I have observed that people of many religions and nationality cultures have cookie tables. Cookie tables are definitely a regional tradition, roughly stretching from Trumbull Co. (or so) in OH to Pittsburgh, PA and are unofficially the most popular part of the entire wedding!

Until you attend a happy event (weddings, graduations, etc) that have cookie table(s), you probably have no idea how tremendous the displays can be. I found these pictures on websites to demonstrate how massive they often are (these sizes are not unusually large). As you can see, most cookies are fancy and time-intensive to make—very special cookies. One of the most popular and traditional cookie is, again, a regional favorite—the clothespin cookie. It is a bite-sized version of a lady lock. YUM!

This is just one of our very wonderful traditions in this region.

TanyaL 12-25-2012 10:45 PM

I am curious to know more about the cookie table tradition. The weddings that I usually go to have a full dinner, either served sit down or buffet, the traditional tiered wedding cake, groom's cake, open bar and a dance. Usually children are not included in the invitations. When you have all the sweet cookies, do you have an open bar? Is a dance part of these weddings?

slk350 12-25-2012 11:16 PM

I have heard of them.I'm originally from Mass. When my sister got married in 1974 (I think) her MIL's side of the family made every kind of Italian cookies for the shower and wedding. Trays and trays of them and had them on a table. And the guest also could take some home in little bags. I thought it was an Italian tradition rather than a regional one.

janRN 12-26-2012 05:35 AM

Tubroh, those tables are lovely and look just like the tables in this area.

If anyone is interested, check out WQED.com. and search for the program The Cookie Table. They delve into the history of this tradition.

Normabeth 12-26-2012 06:47 AM

at my niece's weeding, we had a chocolate candy table, all home made chocolates - was a BIG hit.

danna738 12-26-2012 08:59 AM


Originally Posted by cherrio (Post 5736449)
so nice to hear the comments from a few folks from different regions. gives insight to parts of the country/world. when one of my daughters was married a few years ago we bought chocolates and set them in amongst the cookies. it looked pretty and was a hit. I have not been to a reception yet with a seperate candy table but, I have been to one with an ice cream bar. it was a fall wedding, and was a "children included" reception so it was also a big hit!

and Janrn; Pittsburgh is fairly close so maybe it's something of a regional area thing? I have talked to people from southern Ohio who think it's a weird custom.:p

I am from southern Ohio and it is the custom here for as long as I can remember. A new custom is the candy bar and cupcakes instead of the traditional wedding cake.

Red 12-26-2012 01:30 PM

I've never seen this where I live, but I'm all for it. My family LOVES cookies of any kind. We always have different kinds when we get together.

NancyBelly 12-26-2012 03:03 PM

I'm from Southwest Ohio near Cincinnati and have never heard of a cookie table at a wedding before. I love the idea though......I do LOVE me some cookies!

cherrio 12-26-2012 06:39 PM


Originally Posted by TanyaL (Post 5740762)
I am curious to know more about the cookie table tradition. The weddings that I usually go to have a full dinner, either served sit down or buffet, the traditional tiered wedding cake, groom's cake, open bar and a dance. Usually children are not included in the invitations. When you have all the sweet cookies, do you have an open bar? Is a dance part of these weddings?

open bar/kids or no kids, cookies and or cake etc are all bride/groom/budget decisions.

cherrio 12-26-2012 06:42 PM


Originally Posted by slk350 (Post 5740773)
I have heard of them.I'm originally from Mass. When my sister got married in 1974 (I think) her MIL's side of the family made every kind of Italian cookies for the shower and wedding. Trays and trays of them and had them on a table. And the guest also could take some home in little bags. I thought it was an Italian tradition rather than a regional one.

haha this is an area that is very much Italian so maybe . . . I am Irish but married an Italian with a very large family

captlynhall 12-26-2012 07:17 PM

I have never heard of serving cookies at a wedding reception, but I think it is a brilliant idea. It sounds like so much fun, that several members of the family (and maybe friends too) could be a part of the wedding party by contributing their own special cookies. The take home bags or boxes is a nice touch too.

mrs. fitz 12-26-2012 08:57 PM

I've never heard of this but would love to see it come to my area. I don't like most cakes but cookies, oh my!!!

KayS 12-26-2012 10:50 PM

I think it must be a regional thing. Cool idea. I think anymore weddings are less formal and very different. One this summer had pink as her color and she had a cotton candy machine :) Several lately have a photo booth for guests, complete with clothes to dress up. Never heard of the cookies but sounds fun, maybe that has taken the place of the groom's cake that used to be handed to guests.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:32 AM.