gloves

chocolate or vanilla ice cream

good vanilla

homemade or pizza shop pizza

pizza shop pizza

buttered popcorn or caramel popcorn

Caramel for sure

Wool or cotton socks

cotton socks

chocolate or butterscotch pudding

butterscotch

prunes or plums

plums

hot tea or coffee

hot tea

roses or marigolds

marigolds - roses don't last very long

adult coloring book or game book (crosswords, fill-ins, search etc.)

gamebooks

pullover or button-down tops