Amount of machine quilting
 

I have been a hand quilter up to now. Currently the tops I have completed are piling up and need to be quilted. I know I won't be around long enough to hand quilt them all. I need to send some of them out for machine quilting. I love the softness of a hand quilted quilt. Some of my tops to be quilted are heirloom quality. The heirloom quality custom machine quilting I see is very closely stitched, stippling, mctavishing, echo quilting etc. It is beautiful, but makes the quilt stiff. Will these quilts soften up over time or does the amount of thread used in the quilting always keep it stiffer than a hand quilted quilt? Second question, is it okay to have an heirloom quality quilt machine quilted with less quilting? I am thinking trends come and go and I should have the quilts quilted in a style I like best. On the other hand, I have put years of effort in these tops and I don't want them to look cheap (for want of a better word.)

Your LAer should offer you different styles. I do tell mine that I don't want my quilts heavily quilted. I like the way they look but think they are stiffer than I prefer. Just check with a couple LA to see who can give you what you expect. They all have different styles just as we all have

There maybe local church or ladies from the area who do hand quilting and this would make quilts very nice and soft

You can request minimal quilting; your quilts don't HAVE to be quilted to death. Also, I would choose batting very, very carefully. In my experience, the wrong batting will also render a quilt rather stiff.

Find a good, experienced longarmer. Go to quilt shows, shops, the fair, etc. When you see quilts that have the kind of quilting you want, write down the name of the quilter. Get referrals from your friends, local guild(s) and quilt shops. When you get a fairly consistent list, i.e. the same names keep popping up over and over, call and make an appointment to see some of her examples and discuss your wishes and concerns. A good longarmer will understand that this is a precious investment for you and will take the time to address all your questions.

Sounds like you need to do some serious research to find a long arm quilter you can work well with. You will want to see examples of their quilting. You want to make sure they will respect your quilting ideas. If possible bring photos, or pictures from magazines showing what you have in mind. Plan on sitting with them and taking some time to explain what you want. If they don't want to do this, get someone else. Since it sounds like you have lots of tops, choose one that is less 'heirloom' than the others and have that quilted to make sure that you both have a good understanding of what you want before giving them one of your more prized tops.
As far as stiffness goes, a quilt with dense quilting doesn't necessarily mean that it will be stiff. Batting, backing, quilting thread and the amount of piecing all play a role. And remember the batting determines the maximum distance apart the quilting lines can be, so you need to choose a batt that will support the amount of quilting you have in mind.
You should be able to get a quilter who will work well with you and finish your quilts beautifully.

Actually, I have quilted with a church group for a number of years, but our numbers have dwindled because of death, health, vision, etc. We are down to only four in number. We stopped for the summer, but it looks unlikely that we will start up again this fall. We can't recruit younger quilters. They prefer the quicker methods.

I do my own quilting on my Bernina. I like the look of hand quilting and that is the way I quilt my quilts. I would certainly sit down with the LAQ and discuss you preferences.

I am sad to think you may not be able to finish all your beautiful work.


Machine quilting and hand quilting, to me, are like chalk and cheese. The pattern may be the same but the stitches sure look different.

I think the most important thing is to find someone who will listed to what you want.

Are you pulling the quilts apart ie top and back and then putting in new wadding/ batting? This I'm sure will make a difference to the LA's quilting .

Thanks for all of your responses. It gives me something to think about. In carefully assessing the tops, I am thinking of quilting a couple of them in Big Stitch quilting with Perle cotton or Aurifil 12 wt. It would be much faster and these two tops are not heirloom quality. They are pretty little quilts with applique borders and perhaps would lend themselves to Big Stitch. After talking with quilting friends and the ladies at my local quilt shop, one LA quilter's name keeps popping up. I will contact her-interview her for possible custom work on the special quilts. Have any of you done Big Stitch? If so, what do you think?

Regarding Big Stitch quilting, I must admit that I am not a fan. I prefer quilting to complement the top, and the Big Stitch style just stands out too much. I would rather see good machine quilting to that. I machine quilt my own quilts, and I prefer them soft. I am pretty cautious about how much quilting I put in them so they stay the way I want.

I think this is so true! A design that looks beautiful hand-quilted is not necessarily the best choice for machine quilting, and vice versa.

Edit to add that I think big stitch quilting can look lovely on the appropriate quilt.

peckish, you put it in a nutshell....thanks!

It sounds like you might be like me in many ways. I started quilting because I loved the beautiful hand quilted treasures I'd see on beds or hung from walls. I wanted to do that. But I'm getting older (70 my next birthday) and I'm slow at hand quilting. I don't have a lot of tops because I finish them rather than pile them up but I decided some time ago that I just didn't have the time to hand quilt everything I make. And, I can't afford having them LA quilted. I know those ladies deserve the price they charge but it's just not possible with my pocketbook. I do many of my quilts on my own sewing machines. If it's a special quilt, I still hand quilt it. But if you haven't tried doing machine sewing on your home machine, make up a small piece and try it. That might solve the problem and become another fun thing to do. Of course, perhaps you can afford to have them all done by a LA quilter.

Have you considered sending your quilts out to be hand-quilted, rather than long-armed?

I think you can find people (particularly in Amish areas) that will do hand-quilting for a fee. It's probably more expensive than longarming them but maybe a good option if you have a few that are particularly precious to you?

There is nothing wrong with big stitch as long as your stitches are consistent.

I am with you about the excessive stitching, it's way too much for me too. Ask around and then explain clearly what you want.

All quilting you have done should be to your specifications. If you want them quilted tightly, they will be stiffer, from the extra thread if nothing else, but your LA person should do them the way you want. They can be very similar to hand quilted items

As a LA I appreciate customers giving me guidance on what they want--the density of quilting, the type of design, what they are thinking about thread color(s), type of thread desired and batting. I would recommend that you think about wool bat for that softer feel--even though it' little pricey. And I think that each quilt needs it's "own" quilting--whether it be hand quilting, machine, Big stitch,etc.


A

I have seen many "big stitch" quilts and I really like them. In my opinion, the ones that are the most successful at integrating that kind of quilting are simple, modern quilts; and the handmade/homespun look.