Any wholecloth quilters who use cotton thread?
 

I'd really love to make a wholecloth quilt, but am struggling with the idea of using polyester thread (rayon is totally out of the question because I have a very, very severe contact allergy to it -- and the quilt is for me).

I keep hearing from online teachers that wholecloth quilts should never be done with cotton thread and, in fairness, my favorite quilts tend to be quilted with trilobal poly. I'm generally a purist -- cotton batting/fabric/thread or silk batting/fabric/thread. I sorta cheat with wool and use floss or pearle cotton thread, although I'm thinking of trying some 100% wool thread on my next project.

I really, really want a wool batting (possibly Hobb's Heirloom, but more likely a carded wool batt from a local mill). I'm sorta undecided about whether to do wool fabric (Primitive Gatherings, peacock) or cotton fabric (Cherrywood, indigo), but in any case, I'm really hoping to keep it to all natural fibers.

Does anyone have any experience with this? I'm thinking maybe adding some stuffed work would help. I just keep hearing how "meh" my quilt will be unless I use synthetic threads. I know a lot of you make beautiful quilts with synthetic threads. I know for sure how that would look. Has anyone actually made/seen a wholecloth quilt other than vintage white that was done (FMQ) with cotton thread? Any pics or descriptions -- good or bad -- would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks!!!

I use Hobbs 80/20 batting for my main batting and I use cotton thread by Mettler or Aurifil. I don't know who are your online teachers are but this is what Harriet Hargrave taught me.

Are you planning to hand quilt? Or machine quilt?

Edit: I'd be interested in which online quilters say not to use cotton thread for a wholecloth quilt and what their reasoning is.

As an aside, rayon thread in general is not used for piecing or quilting because it is a relatively weak thread that cannot stand up to abrasion.

If using a carded wool batt from a local mill, you may need to enclose the batt in cheesecloth before layering in order to guard against the wool bearding. Hobbs and Quilter's Dream wool batts are made with newer processes that dramatically reduce the chance of bearding, thus eliminating the need to encase the batt in cheesecloth.

Hmm, not sure why they are advocating against cotton thread. Most of the machine quilted wholecloth quilts I am seeing now at shows and following bloggers are using silk dupioni or the silk blend Radiance as the fabric and silk thread.
Edited to add they are using wool batting.

Polyester thread is shiny and beautiful in a quilt, and yes, many of the quilters today are using it, longarmers are definitely using it. I love it, myself. I think some FMQ quilters are recommending it because of tension problems they've had. I suspect some of those problems would have been rectified with a good needle to thread match and a well-oiled bobbin (so it won't kick back).

In my previous life of quilting (I took a 10 year break) the talk was that you should always use cotton. However, really, there is no need. The idea was that polyester would saw through quilt fabric. However, hand quilting thread is a whole lot stronger than polyester. If polyester would do that, hand quilting thread would too. But it doesn't.

I think you should use whatever you like the best.

I hand quilted a whole cloth wall hanging all in Guterman hand quilting thread (the 10 year old form of it). It was gorgeous. Whole cloth quilting is greatly about creating textures. You can do that with many kinds of thread.

Use what you love (and aren't allergic to). It will all hold up just fine and look gorgeous.

I have never heard the admonishment not to use cotton thread on a wholecloth quilt. However if it's the shine that you want to avoid with poly, there are some that aren't as shiny as the trilobal.

I actually like the shininess -- which is why the teachers (Patti Thompson & Cindy Needham are two, but there are many more) recommend using only poly or rayon thread -- although Patti also says silk is good for microquilting fillers. They were both adamant that cotton thread would not look good & that only synthetics should be used.

I know it's not a question of going through my machine. I FMQ with Aurifil all the time on my baby quilts & have zero issues with it. And my favorite quilter, Heather Thomas, only uses natural fibers -- primarily cotton -- but she does a lot of piecing & applique & couching & whatnot, so the quilting plays a supporting role rather than being the star of the design. So I know I can FMQ with cotton thread, but am now worried it will look terrible as a wholecloth design on a Queen-sized quilt. I have some poly thread for clothing/home dec construction so maybe I just need to quilt up a couple samples & see how things go.

I'm really hoping to quilt this on my DSM. I could hand quilt, but kinda would like to actually have new bedding sometime within the next 2-3 years & I'm a super slow hand quilter. I have a horrible poly comforter right now & almost never use it except as a dust cover during the daytime. I sleep with cotton sheets & a wool blanket & couldn't be happier if I had a lovely wool quilt, too. :)

I like your idea of doing some test mini's to check it out and see how you like it. I'm wondering if the teachers you are talking about are against using a cotton thread because the wt. of the thread is lower (thicker) usually on cotton than on some of the poly's or silk. (most of them are #50-100 wt) and with a whole cloth it seems that most are pretty densely quilted to get the awesome designs in them. Seems like many whole clothes are made with a #50wt for the main design, then something even thinner, like Bottomline, for the filler design. Also, you say you like the shininess of the poly's like trilobal, but cotton is never shiny. If you want a non-shiny poly, check out SoFine or Permacore--both are nice, matte, thinner threads that would probably work fine (and SoFine is available in both #40 and #50 wt--more colors in50). They both look like a finer cotton finish.

What I use depends on the look I want for the quilt -- the quilt usually tells me what it wants. I have used cotton (I like that for table runners and placemats since I may put hot things on them), I use shiny poly for a lot of FMQ but I also use metallic thread when I want a special look. I have couched thicker threads and braids that do not go through my needles if I want something to stand out (pearl cotton, funky yarns and metallic). I really hate to limit myself to one type of thread since there are so many fun threads out there.

Thanks to everyone who has shared their input so far! Going to try the different samples this weekend, hopefully ... and also going to read up a lot more about poly threads. I think they'd be great for art quilts, but this is going on my bed & due to asthma, I will likely be washing the quilt at least every 2 months, possibly even once a month, in commercial machines so I need something that's going to hold up. I haven't had good luck with synthetic threads & regular washing in the past (had to re-quilt my table runner & that was washed much less), but I'm sure part of the issue was I wasn't using a quality brand. I've also accidentally melted embroidery work so I'll have to learn more about wet blocking rather than steam blocking my quilt. Ugh! So much to learn!

Thank you again to all of you for taking so much time to respond & provide so much helpful information!