Quiltingboard Forums - Attic window, does yellow look ok??

Quiltingboard Forums (https://www.quiltingboard.com/)

- Main (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/)

- - Attic window, does yellow look ok?? (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/attic-window-does-yellow-look-ok-t295719.html)

Here's the one attic window quilt I made. My pink sashing was also 1" . I do like how it turned out, but now I wonder if it would have had more of a 3-D effect if I had done what MarionsQuilts had suggested with the "windows" being all the same color , just different shades. Ummm.

https://www.quiltingboard.com/member...36-577690.html

I love it turned out beautiful. I will see how it goes, want to make if for a gal who lives by me, she so sweet and has a lot of health issues as so does her hubby. She feeds the birds everyday and just loves to watch them so I thought she may like it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by NZquilter (Post 8027931)

Pretty birds! The brown looks great for the window sashing.... can you add another brown as well to the bottom?
The thin yellow is nice too. I think I have (or had) some of that bird print too. :)

Thank you, I love this fabric, was gonna try and do a Dresden plate that a gal had done on here some time back, but don't remember the pattern.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mariposa (Post 8027955)

Pretty birds! The brown looks great for the window sashing.... can you add another brown as well to the bottom?
The thin yellow is nice too. I think I have (or had) some of that bird print too. :)

Love the yellow, it makes it really pretty and summery. I think the white should be changed, it is to stark but one important thing to remember, it is your quilt and if you like it then it should stay. Very Pretty.

The reason I asked if it was one block or more is because I think it may be too much yellow. The birds are so sweet and I think the yellow may compete with them.

Quote:

Originally Posted by SusieQOH (Post 8028163)

The reason I asked if it was one block or more is because I think it may be too much yellow. The birds are so sweet and I think the yellow may compete with them.

Totally agree with you, SusieQOH .. my eyes keep going to the yellow strip instead of to the beautiful view outside the window, which should be our focal point with an Attic Windows pattern.

Quote:

Originally Posted by MarionsQuilts (Post 8027895)

.........I have found the most success to be with the same colours - just different shades - so all browns or all yellows. I made one once with different colours, and when I was done, I really wasn't happy with it.
The whole purpose of the attic windows is to create that 3-d effect, and I personally found it much more "3-d" with all the same colour................

That makes total sense ... after all, in doing an Attic Windows, we are emulating an IRL window and the view beyond. Most times the window frames/sashings in our homes are all the same colour, so a quilted one would be the same, and using different fabrics gives us the 3-D effect that the shadows IRL would create. Great explanation and Thank You, MarionQuilts!

Quote:

Originally Posted by crafty3236 (Post 8027818)

if yellow is ok! then do you have a maybe green to go where the white is, I think the white is not the color for there and it maybe the color that needs changed, I do hope that makes sense

I agree - the white is too stark.

Thanks ladies appreciate all feedback.

I think the yellow takes away from the bird, IMHO. Have you tried a neutral like a beige? I think any color other than a neutral would take away from the colors of the birds.