I like the bottom one - I think because of the backing.

Give her the one that most appeals to you. She's your Mom, so she'l like it if you like it.

I like the second one best. I really like the backing! I'm in the process of making one myself. Mine is a winter scene of a red barn. Your Mom would like either one, both turned our great.

Both are outstanding. I like the darker one.

Both are very nice quilts and I think your Mom would love either one and treasure it especially since you made it.

Love them both. Beautiful quilts.