Love it as is. I would only add border if you want it larger.

Copy the border around the medallion. the quilt can benefit from both black and orange.

I love borders on quilts...........it frames the artwork~

Nhweaver your statement says it all you auditioned the dark blue binding & you like that look the best-and I agree with you- go for it! Your DD will love it- but we all know it will be claimed by the fur babies!

Orange border would tie into the center border.

AGHHH! What a quilt! Love all the bright happy colors. I vote for an orange border if you go that way with it. Also peeking out from under the cat scratch quilt is the perfect color for a border. That light turquoise watery blue. Fabulous.
Love this quillt!
peace

I'm sure it will be nice either way but I'd probably add a border to give the eyes a nice resting place. It is a very busy quilt and I think also it would give the quilt balance, as you do have some borders in the middle of the quilt.