Differences in sewing machine needle brands -
I understand that there are different needle systems, sizes, and point styles.
My question is: If needles are the same system, style, and size - would/should they be interchangeable? If not, what are the differences between Singer, Schmetz, and Organ needles? (Or any others out there?) |
I started using Superior needles because they have a longer hole than the others. Less drag on the thread. I love them and have all the different sizes. They also seem to last longer.
|
technically -the SYSTEM denotes what machine it fits, the Style is what type of tip the needle has, and the size is how big in diameter the needle has. One item not address is the type of metal and process the needle goes through to harden it. Some processes make metal more brittle, some make it more flexible. And different mixtures of metal (alloys) can react very differently. And now some companies are putting different coatings on the needle after manufacture.
Then there is quality control- some companies have higher tolerances than others, so if the needle is suppose to be .05268 diameter (number pulled off the ceiling) but one company says +-.005 is close enough and another says .0005 is close enough . . . So there is a lot more going into selection of needle other than System, Style and Size I have over 150 machines with probable over 15 systems. Now days the vast majority of domestic machines use the same system that Singer started using in the late 1800's (and at the time, they were one of the few US companies using that one). I have no idea who is actually making the needles that have the Singer brand name on them. I don't know if SVP owns any needle production factories. Sometimes you find many "brands" are made at the same place, but they have different specifications so being made at the same place in no way means they are similar in quality. |
Originally Posted by catsden
(Post 7948965)
I started using Superior needles because they have a longer hole than the others. Less drag on the thread. I love them and have all the different sizes. They also seem to last longer.
Cari |
Originally Posted by Cari-in-Oly
(Post 7949071)
Organ makes Superior needles, you're just paying more for the name.
Cari |
I use Organ and Schmetz on my Bernina and my vintage Singers. They seem to work well on all of them
|
Whenever my machine is being a brat, a simple change of needle type/size usually does the trick. Needle performance may also depend on the type of fabric, stitching speed, thread, etc. I sometimes use a "topstitch" needle for the embroidery machine and it works fine. I seldom use a "universal" needle but know a few stitchers that use them for everything.
More info for your curiosity. Chrome http://florianisoftware.com/products...hrome-Needles/ Schmetz info https://www.schmetzneedles.com/all-about-needles/# http://www.klasse.com/en/ PS: These trays make great storage units for a stash of needles. I label serger needles with a bright green label so they aren't used in the wrong machine. http://www.joann.com/anti-tarnish-me...%2Bbin&start=1 |
It may be my imagination, but when I switched to the Organ titanium needles from the Organ regular steel needles, they seemed to pierce the fabrics smoother and last a whole lot longer. So that is all I use now.
|
I have recently tried some Organ anti-glue needles and my PQ1500s seems to prefer them for quilting through spray basted items.
Rob |
Originally Posted by redstilettos
(Post 7949079)
I didn't know that!
|
The standard needle configuration from Schmetz and Bernina is 130 705H. This tells you that the distance from the top of the needle to the top of the eye is the same. Singer's number HAx 1, is the same configuration. Then Superior and Organ have a different number for the same length (but I don't know what that is). Top stitch needles, with the longer eye, should still be the same length from the top of the needle to the top of the eye. One timing setting is that the hook should pass at the top of the eye as the needle is on the way up.
Industrial needles and longarm needles usually have a round top, instead of the flat on the back side. And the configuration, or length from top of needle to top of eye will be longer or shorter to accommodate that particular machines timing setting. |
I think with today's machines, the brand name is not that important. The type of needle is what makes the difference. First there is the size, the material it is made of and what is says to use it for. But, as far as the brand name - if it is on sale - it is the right one to use!
|
I always used Schmetz or Klase brand needles until I decided to try Janome needles in my Janome machine. I do notice a difference in it took care of any skipped stitches especially when pivoting at points or going through thicker areas. It must be that they are a smidgen longer so they pick up the bobbin thread better. I've used both the purple tip and red tip ones with good results.
|
Originally Posted by rryder
(Post 7949408)
I have recently tried some Organ anti-glue needles and my PQ1500s seems to prefer them for quilting through spray basted items.
Rob |
Originally Posted by citruscountyquilter
(Post 7949763)
I always used Schmetz or Klase brand needles until I decided to try Janome needles in my Janome machine. I do notice a difference in it took care of any skipped stitches especially when pivoting at points or going through thicker areas. It must be that they are a smidgen longer so they pick up the bobbin thread better. I've used both the purple tip and red tip ones with good results.
Cari |
Originally Posted by Macybaby
(Post 7948967)
technically -the SYSTEM denotes what machine it fits, the Style is what type of tip the needle has, and the size is how big in diameter the needle has. One item not address is the type of metal and process the needle goes through to harden it. Some processes make metal more brittle, some make it more flexible. And different mixtures of metal (alloys) can react very differently. And now some companies are putting different coatings on the needle after manufacture.
Then there is quality control- some companies have higher tolerances than others, so if the needle is suppose to be .05268 diameter (number pulled off the ceiling) but one company says +-.005 is close enough and another says .0005 is close enough . . . So there is a lot more going into selection of needle other than System, Style and Size I have over 150 machines with probable over 15 systems. Now days the vast majority of domestic machines use the same system that Singer started using in the late 1800's (and at the time, they were one of the few US companies using that one). I have no idea who is actually making the needles that have the Singer brand name on them. I don't know if SVP owns any needle production factories. Sometimes you find many "brands" are made at the same place, but they have different specifications so being made at the same place in no way means they are similar in quality. |
Bear, I mostly use Schmetz and Organ. I like them both and don't really see a difference. I just got a great deal on Organ from Amazon. I'm not going to need needles for awhile.
|
How does one find out that Organ makes Janome and Superior Needles. Is there a Organ web site with this information?
|
https://www.superiorthreads.com/educ...le-infographic - for Superior needles.
I forget where I found out about the Janome needles. Cari |
Originally Posted by ccthomas
(Post 7950116)
How does one find out that Organ makes Janome and Superior Needles. Is there a Organ web site with this information?
|
I use Schmetz needles at work in twin needle Consew industrial machines. They are extremely durable. A vendor stuck me with Groz-Beckett needles and the were terrible. I was going through 2 or more a day because they developed burrs and the eye was poorly polished and the thread was shredding. Never again. The Schmetz needles last at least a week with very heavy use.
|
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:33 AM. |