I would just toss it but that's my personality. I don't even want to fix my own mistakes so I sure as heck wouldn't fix someone else's! I'd find it too frustrating to have to take the entire thing apart to fix it and since quilting is supposed to be fun, I just wouldn't be able to bring myself to attempt it.

I would be at the fabric store (or in my stash) picking out the perfect fabrics to sew up a new Bear Paw quilt. Any excuse to buy fabric. :)

Is it still considered a Bears Claw block if it has 3 HST instead of 2?

Usually when a picture of something is posted on eBay, the item is shown to its best advantage. It's relatively rare, for a seller to show the 'ugly' side of something he/she is trying to sell. My guess is that the OP saw an eBay photo of the top, which the seller made sure looked pretty good.

I see no irony, in the fact that she tried to fix a few mistakes.

That is one hot mess! I would halt all attempts to salvage.

I once read that if one don't like the quilt she is working on: don't throw it away but donate it! Somewhere there is someone who likes it and is pleased to get a quilt! And there are many organisations that will make these "unloved" quilts ready and give them to someone who needs a little bit shelter or warmth!

It would be so much easier and lead to better results to just piece a quilt of your own rather than take that one apart and redo it. what a mess. I think if you really want to keep it, you just put it back the way it was and accept it as imperfect or cop it into strange pieces and make a crazy quilt out of it.

I had a friend who I had met in April and talked a good talk about being a good quilter. Just before she moved again, I was the recipient of one of her quilts to fix. Sometimes there are quilter's that see nothing wrong with what they make. I found out that my friend has ADD. I just attached the metallic gold rick rack to hide most of the mismatched seam allowances. Now I am trying to decide if I want to even attempt to put an outside border on the quilt.

I wouldn't take any more apart. If you don't want to keep it, I would still finish it and donate it. We send some of the quilts we make in the church's sewing group to Haiti or Africa where they will be appreciated.

I wouldn't take it apart and fix it. These are the options I see.

1. Someone will love the quilt and not know all the errors you see. Most quilt guilds make charity quilts. You can contact one of them and donate it as it is. They will quilt it and donate to someone.
2. You can just quilt it as it is and use it as a utility quilt....the one you use to put on the ground, wrap Grandma's dresser in it when you are moving it, etc. Or give to the dog to lay on.
3. Or you can use it as a practice quilt, to try all different types of quilting on.

Personally, I'd just find a guild and pass it on.

I would check on the red bleeding. I really believe in charity quilts so I would test it and then if its bleeds I'd finish it, quilt it and wash it with a number of color catchers and lots of water and then donate it. My guild donates many, many quilts. You can't believe the joy the quilts provide and the new owners don't care about perfect piecing.
Good luck

Yes this! I would make an utility quilt. It is just not worth it to take it apart.