There are some nice Christmas fabrics out there right now. I'd look for something in greens and/or red to make it closr to lap quilt size and bind it in black. It is very pretty.

What about some red and green 4 patch squares (2-1/2 x 2-1/2 squares for the 4-patch) all around it with a couple of borders? That would make it larger.

Really great ideas everyone. I bought two panels, so I am going to do them both different. I'll post pictures when I get them done. Thank you all so much for your feedback!!!

What about a white or light gray to pick up and repeat color of horses then red or green, bind with red or green