If I am doing a log cabin, I usually just strip piece it. Cutting is not my favorite chore, but I'd say its up to you

All my pieces are precut. For each side I take the correct size and add it to all of the blocks on that side. I just finished a 100 block log cabin.....and the whole thing goes so fast. The whole quilt was finished in less that 2 weeks, that included all the cutting, because i used all my scraps:
http://www.quiltingboard.com/t-150071-1.htm

This is what the piecing looks like with pre cut strips:

I'll never do pieces again. Much prefer Eleanor's method.

I had to do pieces once because the swap was 10 inch squares. In fact, I plan to sell my log cabin set as soon as I get one small project done that uses them.

I've made a bunch of log cabins, but I have no idea at all what a "log cabin set" is. Can you explain?

I like very scrappy log cabins with narrow logs, so for me, the strip method, and then squaring up, is the best way. I like having the freedom to make design choices every step of the sewing process.

If I were doing a planned, limited fabric choice lop cabin quilt, then I could see some value to cutting pieces before sewing.

My preference in log cabins is for that traditional, scrappy, vibrant effect. I just think it makes for a more interesting design. I think having some variation in the widths of the logs works well too. You can still have the blocks end up the same size, by trimming your final block.

RST

I strip piece and have never had a problem. When squaring up, the blocks are never more than a couple threads off. If your strips are cut accurately, the seam is an accurate scant 1/4 inch, and it is pressed correctly, your block should be fine, unless you are stretching your fabric as you sew.

Ditto.

Here's the strip method. You start with two long strips of fabric, then press
and cut into those pairs of squares then take those pairs to the machine and
add the next strip and so on.
http://stitchesinplay.typepad.com/st...-tutorial.html

Chain piecing is just taking all your cut strips and sewing one after the other.
First you sew two squares then add the next strip, etc. In other words you
do all the cutting first then sew. Clear as mud? :wink:

Personally, I found that any short-cut method ends up wonky for me.
If I do a log cabin I will starch then cut all my pieces then chain piece.

The strip method. To keep the block square, just square it up after each round. Comes out right every time.

I like cutting out the pieces. Just like any other patchwork.