Quiltingboard Forums

Quiltingboard Forums (https://www.quiltingboard.com/)
-   Main (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/)
-   -   OH NO!!!!!!!!! I use plastic for alot of things and (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/oh-no-i-use-plastic-alot-things-t88974.html)

Mattee 01-10-2011 06:18 AM

Has anyone ever opened a plastic bag or tote and smelled something that smells like chemicals? That's the plastic releasing gases. If those gases remain trapped inside the container, they may, depending on the dyes used and fiber content, alter the fabric inside or its appearance. That's why lining the container doesn't necessarily help. I don't think Clotilde's just made this up.

fabric_lover 01-10-2011 06:38 AM

I used to store a major part of my stash in large plastics but after travelling a bit and storing suitcases, thought why am I storing suitcases in suitcases? So........in went the fabrics and when I am out of storage , I pop into thrift stores and buy suitcases--nice ones, small medium or large for a VERY reasonable price, wash them, then when dried store more fabrics. I separated them by color -but now future stash is quite messy-- and the suitcase rollers and handles make it very convenient to move without to much strain. No trouble with gremlins so far and it's been many yrs.

And the suitcases are "breathable".

k9dancer 01-10-2011 06:46 AM

I have some fabric that was stored for years in plastic tubs. It is fine.
I cannot say the same for fabric that was stored in cardboard boxes. That gets dirty when the corners wear or the box breaks or when mice find their way in.
Stick with tubs that have covers that lock and you should be fine.

mbmquilts 01-10-2011 07:02 AM

Plastic does not breath so if any moisture is on the fabric or anything related it could mold the entire project or the entire box or bag.

gramarraine 01-10-2011 08:00 AM

I have heard that plastic bags, containers that are air tight do not allow any air movement and dry out the fabric. If the fabric is dry it might tear or get holes in it easy. I don't know if that is correct or not, just what I have heard.

Marysewfun 01-10-2011 08:42 AM

The only time I have experienced "brown spots" in regard to plastic bags is in throwing some old knit-type tops in them (the clothes were clean, just getting rid of then temporarily - Hah!) and after sitting in the back of a closet for awhile, I opened the bags and noticed that sweat spots or if there were any imbedded grease spots in the items that there were permanent brown spots (couldn't even bleach them out). I also had put them in cheap shopping type plastic bags. Other than that, I have used plastic for years and haven't experienced problems.
Marysewfun

Janetd 01-10-2011 09:03 AM

I've been using plastic for years and no problem here.

misseva 01-10-2011 09:13 AM

I know from experience that storing clothes/material in cardboard boxes will cause brown spots because of the acid in them. BUT I'm wondering if plastic leaf bags are the problem and not plastic bins? On the other hand, I was given some material scraps recently when a lady cleaned out her storage shed. The black plastic bags were actually cumbling apart and all the material was just fine. I know I would never store a quilt in a plastic bag - but everything else...????

BellaBoo 01-10-2011 09:24 AM

I had one of my childhood dresses hanging in my closet for years in a dry clearner's plastic bag. When my DD wanted to wear the dress we discovered brown spots on the dress from the plastic. The dry cleaner couldn't get them out so he suggested for me to let him wash it, I wouldn't lose anything, the dress couldn't be worn with the spots. The spots came out and the dress looked good as new. The fabric was synthetic so I doubt the spots would have come out of cotton. I wouldn't store fabric in bags for long term. I've never had a problem with the plastic bins. The white acid free cardboard boxes are perfect. Wal Mart sells them cheap.

Deborah12687 01-10-2011 09:33 AM

I have not had brown spots on fabric storing it in plastic bins but my friend didn't dry some of her fabric fully and she had brown spots. Think it might come from from the laundry soap.

jamannix 01-10-2011 10:41 AM

Sherriequilts - please don't ruin your knee surgery by rushing back to save your fabrics. I am a procrastinator and many of my fabrics have been in cheap plastic bags for >5 years in a hot attic. I am gradually buying clear plastic sweater boxes at our local container store [$5/box, so as my budget permits] and transferring fabrics that go with a specific planned quilt into these boxes with
the picture or pattern of the quilt. So far all my fabrics have been like new - no
sun damage and no brown spots and no mold.
So-focus on your rehab and physical therapy so that you can be restored to good health and restart your quilting.
Sincerely - Judy M.D.

jamannix 01-10-2011 10:42 AM

Sherriequilts - please don't ruin your knee surgery by rushing back to save your fabrics. I am a procrastinator and many of my fabrics have been in cheap plastic bags for >5 years in a hot attic. I am gradually buying clear plastic sweater boxes at our local container store [$5/box, so as my budget permits] and transferring fabrics that go with a specific planned quilt into these boxes with the picture or pattern of the quilt. So far all my fabrics have been like new - no sun damage and no brown spots and no mold.
So-focus on your rehab and physical therapy so that you can be restored to good health and restart your quilting.
Sincerely - Judy M.D.

bjnicholson 01-10-2011 11:36 AM

I have heard not to use Dry Cleaner's plastic and it should be removed from the cloths as soon as you bring it home. But that's all I've ever worried about. Nothing else has ever had spots of any kind.

TootieAnn 01-10-2011 12:08 PM

I use plastic bins to store fabric too. I've never had a problem with it. I think things get ruined more easily from not being stored in something fairly sturdy, but that's just my opinion. I wouldn't worry about it. I really don't know what I would do if I didn't store things in plastic bins.

Corky 01-10-2011 12:27 PM

I really think it has more to do with humidity. I keep my fabrics away from direct sun light, too. And, no pins get stored in fabrics for long, either.

Have stored for years in plastic, no problems, but I do open them now and again (just to fondle them!) and have not seen any problems. Love to be able to see through the totes

I think plastics are more unhealthy for human consumption than for our fabrics.

IMHO!

Corky 01-10-2011 12:29 PM

Not sure if they still use the same chemicals nowadays, but years ago (?15?) we were warned to air out all items from teh dry cleaners before using, especially sleeping bags due to the chemicals being toxic.

Can't remember the last thing I took to a dry cleaner..... Oh yeah! My red wool jacket!


Originally Posted by bjnicholson
I have heard not to use Dry Cleaner's plastic and it should be removed from the cloths as soon as you bring it home. But that's all I've ever worried about. Nothing else has ever had spots of any kind.


Mattee 01-10-2011 12:52 PM

Many of them do still use the same chemicals, although some dry cleaners are not popping up in some metro areas with "green" cleaning chemicals. They aren't actually completely safe, but many of them are better than the standard dry cleaning chemicals. It's worth looking into if you do any dry cleaning.


Originally Posted by Corky
Not sure if they still use the same chemicals nowadays, but years ago (?15?) we were warned to air out all items from teh dry cleaners before using, especially sleeping bags due to the chemicals being toxic.

Can't remember the last thing I took to a dry cleaner..... Oh yeah! My red wool jacket!


Originally Posted by bjnicholson
I have heard not to use Dry Cleaner's plastic and it should be removed from the cloths as soon as you bring it home. But that's all I've ever worried about. Nothing else has ever had spots of any kind.



kclausing 01-10-2011 12:55 PM

I use bins and bags. Never had an issue yet. Though I could see if it were keptin a damp area that mold could grow inside plastic due to lack of ventilation, thus causing brown spots.

G'ma Kay 01-10-2011 01:03 PM

if a bug gets in the plastic storage container with the fabric, you will have brown spots. if they are sealed well, it should not be a problem.

cbjlinda 01-10-2011 02:30 PM

I have stored my fabric in plastic containers and baggies for years without a problem.

sewmuch 01-10-2011 02:36 PM

Another plastic user for years and no problems...even store
Xmas decor in plastic tubs in shed outside, no problems...

p38flygirl 01-10-2011 04:02 PM

I will just have to take my chances...I always use plastic bins..

garysgal 01-10-2011 04:41 PM

I have stored fabric in plastic tubs for years and I have never found any spots or anything on any of it.

JeanDal 01-10-2011 05:20 PM


Originally Posted by JulieR

Originally Posted by Vanuatu Jill
I have had all fabric for complete quilts (not cut yet) stored in Zip Lock bags for a few years, and when I took them out, there were no problems-that's all the experience I'v had with storing long term in plastic.

Ditto! Anyway, I think I'll take my chances with brown spots when the odds I'll get a mouse, a moth or other downer are much higher

Same for me.

martha jo 01-10-2011 06:32 PM

I have stored fabric in rubbermaid tubs for years and never had a spot or any problem.

jaciqltznok 01-10-2011 06:52 PM

plastic not only gives off toxic gas when exposed to extreme temp changes, the UV rays can penetrate it and cause undo aging/spots on the fabrics. If stored in air tight containers, you cotton can dry rot.
No one here (on this QB list) seems to realize that cotton is a living breathing fiber...if you cut off the air supply it will die(rot)....

quiltgrammyt2 01-10-2011 06:54 PM


Originally Posted by jaciqltznok
plastic not only gives off toxic gas when exposed to extreme temp changes, the UV rays can penetrate it and cause undo aging/spots on the fabrics. If stored in air tight containers, you cotton can dry rot.
No one here (on this QB list) seems to realize that cotton is a living breathing fiber...if you cut off the air supply it will die(rot)....

How do you store your fabric?

Mattee 01-10-2011 07:05 PM

I think I'm confused by your use of the phrase "living fiber." What exactly does that mean? I'm only used to defining "life" in a biology class, and cotton in a fabric doesn't qualify, as it doesn't excrete waste, absorb food, or reproduce, just to name a few. I think we're having a terminology problem. What does it mean?


Originally Posted by jaciqltznok
plastic not only gives off toxic gas when exposed to extreme temp changes, the UV rays can penetrate it and cause undo aging/spots on the fabrics. If stored in air tight containers, you cotton can dry rot.
No one here (on this QB list) seems to realize that cotton is a living breathing fiber...if you cut off the air supply it will die(rot)....


Berta48 01-10-2011 08:01 PM

I have a lot of fabric in the big blue plastic tubs for several years no problem yet.

grammysharon 01-10-2011 10:18 PM

I think as long as they are not in the sun in plastic you are OK! :D

cheryl rearick 01-11-2011 12:11 AM

I use to live in WA state, had plastic tubs with lids sitting on my back porch for 10 years, Even rain mist would touch them, nothing ever got damp or moldy.. maybe I was very lucky, Not all material, some clothing and odds and ends.

dottientx 01-11-2011 02:17 AM

I've had fabrics stored in plastic totes since in the 1960's when I started building my stash for when I retired 30 years later. I still have a lot of this fabric and it's just fine. No odor! No fading! No dust!

starshine 01-11-2011 06:07 AM

I have had an experience with brown discoloration on a couple of cotton fabrics. They were stored in my attic in plastic bags (trash type bags) one was a piece of fabric and some was leftover from cutting out a dress for my daughter. They weren't in the same bag, or box but these 2 items had some areas of brown discoloration. I was going through all my fabric especially "scraps" as I wanted to use the scraps from her dress in her quilt I'm making (there will be enouch of her dress fabric to get a patch :-)). Most of the fabrics were fine except for these 2. So it probably was the bag, being in a box could have an effect as well. So it could be just random occurance, and maybe I won't use trash bags to store fabric or out of season clothes anymore.

Glenda Kay 01-11-2011 07:32 AM


Originally Posted by Mattee
The solid plastics can also offgas, or release VOC's, which are chemicals that can alter the coloration of some fabrics, depending on the dyes used. Is it a common problem? Probably not. I, however, have had it happen with some hand-dyed fabrics. If it's a fabric you really care for, I suggest not using plastic.

What's the alternative? How do you store your fabric?

EagarBeez 01-11-2011 08:37 AM

here is a link from e how telling just how to store cotton fabric

http://www.ehow.com/how_6021666_stor...on-fabric.html

Mattee 01-11-2011 09:19 AM

I store my fabric in a closet on wooden shelves, with acid-free tissue paper between the shelves and the fabric if I care a lot about the fabric. If it's Joann's stuff that I care less about, it's just on the wooden shelves. I try not to use plastic at all unless I have to. I also try not to have so much stuff that some of it needs to be stored elsewhere. I have a healthy fabric stash, but in general, if it's in storage, I'm not enjoying it, and I have to ask myself, do I really need so much stuff, anyway? If my home starts to overflow, a trip to the local charity drop-off station is in order.


Originally Posted by Glenda Kay

Originally Posted by Mattee
The solid plastics can also offgas, or release VOC's, which are chemicals that can alter the coloration of some fabrics, depending on the dyes used. Is it a common problem? Probably not. I, however, have had it happen with some hand-dyed fabrics. If it's a fabric you really care for, I suggest not using plastic.

What's the alternative? How do you store your fabric?


Marvlin 01-11-2011 12:52 PM

I store all my fabrics in plastic bins with tight lids. I've done this for many, many years and have never had a moment's problems with my fabric. I replaced all my plastic bins after christmas because they stacked better in my sewing room and did not find even one spot. I never have however stored fabrics in plastic grocery bags so I would not know what results you might get. Silica crystals placed in plastic bins will help with any moisture problems.

biscuitqueen 01-12-2011 06:33 PM

the problems you might incounter would be moisture build up or condensation.

packratpattyart 01-13-2011 03:40 PM

I have had fabric come out with spots on them but these are usually fabrics that I have handle a couple of times and put away,meaning my hands were not as clean as they should have been. I have worked with a of wedding dresses and that's were I have seen this happen the most.

Dee 01-13-2011 09:11 PM

I have used plastic for years with no problem.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:42 AM.