The first one, because I'm more drawn to brights. But the second is quite soothing with its low contrast.

First one.

Watson

I like the second one. I'm one of those that does not like a lot of contrast, and really do not like a "pop" of color that designers are always saying you need. To me it often looks like something out of place LOL!!

The good part, I've yet to meet a quilt that someone didn't fall in love with, so they are ALL good :)

I like the bolder/brighter one but depends on the customer.

No preference...like both.

I like them both and at first leaned towards the 1st one but on 2nd look decided that since you will be adding applique I would have also chosen the 2nd one because it's muted and won't distract from the bolder flowers and butterflies. Can't wait to see the finished project...please share!

I think it would depend on the appliqué pieces

The second one. The appliques will show up better on these muted colors.

I like the first one best but both are pretty.

***
*** One
***