I haven't tried the toothpick method yet, but I imagine the roughness of the wood would grab the little threads better and make it easier to sweep it all under.

Well you can put your DNA on it and it stays moist which helps to dampen the fabric a bit and that is what helps turn your fabric. They are stronger and have a better grip than the original ones.
Try it you may like it!!!!!
Also buy your self a pair of those glasses that have a headband and they sell a Craft stores like Michaels. You have a better look at what you are appliquing.

Yes, and although it doesn't sound very hygienic, it helps tons if you moisten them--lick them or dip them in a little water. Someone showed me that trick too and I've been amazed at how much easier it makes turning the edges smoothly.

Hmmm, sounds like a good enough reason to go to Cracker Barrel for dinner! Especially since I just started an applique project!! What perfect timing!

the wood of the toothpick grabs the fabric better than the smooth needle--downside i found was keeping the tooth pick in my mouth between use--i re trained my self by putting it in an eggcup close handy

ive been using toothpicks for over 10 years- that's how i was taught to do needleturn- but i don't drive the 78 miles necessary to get to cracker barrel- my grocery store has a nice selection of toothpicks. the ones i choose are wood, round, long (about 3" i think) very inexpensive and have served me well.

I like mint flavored toothpicks better.

Funny, I have a book for quilting tips that I haven't picked up in a year. Yesterday as I was cleaning my sewing room, I ran across it, opened it randomly and guess what it was all about? You got it, using toothpicks to applique!! and I had never heard of it before. lol

Yes cheap toothpicks do the job!!!!

I've been appliqueing for 5 years and the teacher showed us how to use the toothpick as an option. I like it much better than turning with a needle, however, I do look kind of funny sitting there with a toothpick hanging out from my lip. I also use the round toothpicks that are double-pointed. The flat ones feel too flimsy. One of the restaurants I go to has individually wrapped toothpicks. I always pick up 6 or so on my way out.

Also, I've always bought the plain toothpicks, not the colored. I would be afraid the color would transfer to my fabric (not to mention my tongue).