#3 is my choice, I too think that the solid blue is too wide in the first two pics. And although we can't see the whole quilt, the piano keys may be too busy, the eye needs a place to rest. I sometimes place some flying geese units within the border to point the way back into the quilt

I really like number one. You've done a beautiful job.

#3 first choice then #1

#1, the others take away from the quilt it self. The blue no'esw not need to be out done.

I like # 1 too.

I like #1 and #3, can't decide which.

I like #1 as well! Piano key borders aren't so difficult if you strip piece them (sew long strips together and then cut)Good luck! I see some fabrics from my stash that I just love!

My favorite is number three. I like the frame. The piano keys seem too busy to me.

I like the first one the best, it just pops. God bless.

#2 is the best looking and attention grabbing of the three. However, by grabbing one's attention, it brings the eye back tothe center of the quilt, which is a good thing. Belles :thumbup: