#2 would be my choice.

My choice is #2. #3 is to plain #1 too much blue. I really like piano keys I have done one and yes its more work but really pretty.

Definitely choice 1.

I am sorry you had difficulty doing the piano key borders. It is my go to choice for a quick border because it is so easy to adjust if you miscalculated along the way.

It's hard to choose between #1 and #2, but if I have to, I choose #2.

I, too, love number one. It's very pretty.

I like the one with the blue border and the piano keys. The first one - while very pretty - almost asks for another broader border in my opinion.

I like two and three better than one. JMHO.

Kyia

I like #1.

# 1 Absolutely.

Go with #3 for all of the above reasons. Nice colors.

Love #1. It really makes the rest of the quilt come alive. My attention was drawn from the border inward to your lovely blocks.

I Like # 1

Definitely No 1!! Beautiful !! Quilts are time consuming and we do put our hearts and souls into them, dont we?

I prefer the 3rd. border. It has a more finished look. I think borders #1 and #2 take away from the main quilt. Love the colors and well, everything about the quilt.

I fully agree here, but it is your quilt. What makes you feel good?

2

# 1 always my favorite

I like the piano key one and have used piano key borders often. I do dislike cutting out the blocks, but I recently got the accuquilt go which has a die that is the perfect size for the blocks.

i vote for the first one

#1 FOR ME. I love the blues and yellows in your quilt.

Hi there. They are all lovely and would suit, but I like #3 as the plain border just has a lovely finish and seems to frame the quilt nicely. Also, this makes the pattern stand out and not seem to be too busy. :)

I love the piano key border. Very nice.

I like # 3

My vote is number 2... will be anxious to know what you finally decide.

I like #1 best but do agree that #3 will allow for some nice quilting space! Love the colors and can't wait to see what you choose.

I think #1 is beautiful, but I always try to do the first border that stops the business of the quilt. That is a great border, but kind of continues the quilt look. Just my opinion. But the beauty of quilting is that what we design is of out liking and our personality. Good job.

I like #2 the best.

Gee, I like #2.. Looks great to me... Number one is too busy.. number 3 too bland..

I love #1, then #2

I like the 3rd choice but I'm not sure I would put the extra blue around the outside. I like it with just the brown.

I like choice #2. I think the thicker colored squares goes better with the border. #1 in my opinion doesn't look as good because the first border (before the keys) is too thick and makes it look like (with the outer border) the keys are in jail or something. #3 looks nice too but it looks like it was done because it was quick and easy. Therefore I would choose #2. Just my biatchy opinion tonight.

I like # 2. Very nice :thumbup:

I love choice #1 too. And piano keys aren't so bad, just strip piecein the colors you want, cut into sections, and sew them together. Not so bad.

My choice is number 3.

I like #1 first, then #2. I think #3 looks too blah.

I vote for...................NUMBER ONE!!!!!

I like #'s 2 and 3 but can't decide which one I like best.

I love the piano keys. I have done several and love the way they look. Good Luck.

Go with the one you like best. All 3 look good in the small pictures, but what do you think when you look at the real mccoy?