I'd be glad to take the flack with you! I don't "get it" either!

Because the older machines (think featherweight, etc) also have a perfect straight stitch, equal or better than any of the modern machines, and many have more stitches, and you don't take an advanced degree, or take classes, to use all of their features. The older machines don't have a "shelf life", unlike modern machines that require a fair amount of servicing, and whose electronic components are vulnerable to all sorts of things including obsolescence. The older machines are much lighter and more compact than the newer, bigger machines, and these well-built, all metal machines, if cared for properly, will never wear out, unlike modern machines. If your electricity goes off you can still sew on a treadle, unlike a modern machine. And I certainly question the "reliability" part of your claim. I'm sure Billy can give you a lot more reasons, but these are some of mine.

I learned how to sew in the 50's. I had to thread the needle, cut the thread, etc. myself so I don't mind taking the time to do it now. I rarely use anything but a straight or a zig zag stitch so why invest in something I won't use and probably wouldn't like.

It gives me a lot of satisfaction to sit and piece a quilt on a treadle that was made 115 years ago.

If someone wants to give me a fancy machine that has almost perfect tension and sews a variety of stitches I wouldn't refuse it - but I wouldn't consider buying one.

I love my Singer treadle. It sews through anything! If you take a lot of workshops or classes, a Featherweight is nice (don't have one but have tried one at a class). The name says it all, the are very light to tote around. I must admit that I just don't trust older electric sewing machines (old cords and motors) so I don't have any. I think it's great that people are refurbishing older machines to use. It seems that everything made today is cheaper to throw away than repair.

1.They are a tank! Not like the plastic stuff today.
2.All heavy duty parts, my dh can repair anything on them for me unlike the new ones.
3.I like to think of all the women who had sewn on them and what they would of made. Kinda brings you closer to the machines and the history.
4.Not pricey like the new ones
5. Just plain fun!
I guess I don't even need any reasons, I just love them!

My treadle is lots of fun, good exercise and sews very nicely, and as stated above-it's my "insurance" if the electric goes out! Haven't had my 15-91 very long, but it will be my machine to learn fmq on. My featherweight is going to go on vacation with me-takes lots less room in the jeep than my Brother portable. And-they are pretty machines!

Gaigai said pretty much what I am thinking. I never used a treadle but I would like to "treadilize" my 15 if I can find a cabinet.
The craftsmanship of the old machines is amazing.Not only do they work great but they are so beautiful! The detailing is wonderful! I have a Bernina and love it but I'm using my old Singers more and more.
The sound of the old machines is very pleasing to me and they are so reliable. I also love antiques so I guess it's natural for me to be drawn to them. You can't get me in a furniture store except to buy a sofa :D

Why? Because my mom's old Singer Red Eye is easy. No fussing with the settings - I just sit and sew.

Janet

I love the featherweights from the 50's because I saw my mother and aunts sewing on them. They stitch a great straight stitch, the are EASY to take to classes and sewing trips. great for piecing work. Nostalgia.

They are the best of form meeting function. Beauty and utility rolled into one. There is also the fact that they can be maintained and repaired by almost anyone, never have to have their computerized components updated, and they don't have to be treated with kid gloves in case they should break.