which is better: chocolate over mint and caramel or Caramel over mint with chocolate?

I like the 2nd one, just seems to "pop" more. :)

I like the chocolate on the outside, I usually finish mine with a dark color.

I think I like the second 1 best of all. would love to see it when it is finished

I like the chocolate on top.

Door #2.

Ok here is my opinion for what it is worth. The choclate seems to have a better flow to it. The quilt seems too dark and the caramel brightens it up and shows more definition to the quilt in the chocolate pic. Does that make sense? Anyway I like the second pic the best.

I like the 2nd one ...

Second, really pops the minute you look at it.

Same here. Just waiting to hear from DIL to see which she wants. But it's chocolate over caramel and mint for me also. When she purchased the materials, I had a hard time envisioning what to do with the colors, but I thought the lover's know pattern would work best. As first I was a bit bored with the color choices, now I am liking it more as I go. Hopefully she will like it when it's finished, I am really trying to please her, we haven't had the best of relationships and she's a bit difficult (grew up with a silver spoon, if you know what I mean).