I like the fabric choices in #2

Sorry, diplomacy has never been my strong point. I like #1.

Both cute but my favorite is number 2.

Love both of them but have to pick the second because of the red shoes!

I'd have to vote for #2 because of the spider webby background and the witch is wearing the ruby slippers!

Love the colors in number two! Sorry, not very dipolmatic am I? LOL!

I love this pattern and want to make it this year. I cannot decide. They are BOTH equally cute. I might lean towards #2 because of the background used but it is hard to choose the best. Great job.

2nd

2 because of the red shoes.

Wow this sure is fun to see all of the difference in opinions... Good thing we dont all like the same thing or this life would be very boring. lol. I will be trying to finish up number 2 today sometime as my daughter leaves tomorrow for home and if I dont do it she wont have time with all three boys when she gets home.