I like pic #3, I think the darker background makes the star pop. But what you thinks looks best is up to you, actually, none of the backgrounds are wrong !!!

#4 gets my vote!

I like #4!!! I think you did a great job but I think I would have started with something a little bigger lol You are couragous to do such small work!!! Cant wait to see what you do with it

I like 2 the best, but any of them would work.

i vote for #2.

Definitely #4. The star stands out better that way. Very pretty.

I like #2 ~ then #4

I like #4!!

I also like #4.

i like the first one