I would do just the small blue binding :)

Not sure what you mean - small blue binding with the blue piano key border, or with the beige border? I do value all of you opinions. Really confused about this. Something just doesn't feel right about it, trying to figure it out. The gal is paying good money for it and I want her to be happy. I will definately give her all the choices and let her make the final decision.

I much prefer the beige border in the last pic. There's something strange about the other one.
Beautiful quilt!! I love blues!! :D
Let us know what she decides.

I agree that the larger boarder helps frame the quilt.

I like it that way. I would just add a final border to top it all off

I like them both and have no real preference. Good job.

I see no problem with the second border. Looks great to me.

I liked the piano keys but would sew a strip on edge like the strip you did before the piano keys and then add the binding in blue. It would balance the border. I also like the tan border. But I think it does need some kind of border. Anxious to see what you end up doing. Beautiful quilt. Sally

I like the beige boarder and then the blue binding

I like it with the extra blue border.