Is it me or are threads repeated?
 

Some days I realize I am losing my mind but I have more of those "day sha voo" (yes, I know it's spelled wrong) days on this forum than anywhere else. On the old board, each day brought new threads. On this one, am I crazy or are they repeated? I KNOW I read that one yesterday, but I swear, here it is again. Do I have any sisters and brothers out there?

When someone responds to a current thread it moves back to the top---------so you are seeing the threads again. Personally, I like it that way. Easy to see new responses.

I have had times lately where I see a post that hasn't changed colors (indicating it's been read), and yet I know I've read that post already. So I don't know. It always throws me for a loop, too.

Yeah, the new board will bring up old threads when a new response has been posted. I really, really, really, really miss the old 'unread topics' mechanism, but I guess that's progress.

Sometimes a new thread will have a subject line identical to a previous thread-------or very close. That can throw us off track, too.

All true. Sometimes a new thread is started just like an old one because the person posting didn't see the old one. For example, there is a new thread on "knee lift" mechanisms, and there was another one on that subject not long ago. Not a problem.

GrannieAnnie is right. I've had threads come back from months after it has been posted. Sometimes someone will go to your profile and look up your last threads posted if they are interested in your work. If they make a comment on it, it will bring it back up to the top of the page.

Go into the archives of each subject and it lists articles in reverse order. Until I found that on the new board, I was ready to give up. Look under pictures, main, etc. Sometimes it is several frames down but it is there and well worth it.

Thought it was just me. Glad that I am not going over the edge!

You are not alone.

I noticed after the last maintenance that the things you've read don't stay marked as read. I've also noticed people start threads about the same general things over and over. A lot of that is because they're new here.

And too .. there's often the same subject started one after the other ... same discussion, different thread!

Eg. how many threads about HSTs and how to make them were there on the weekend?

My point of entry to the threads is via the Archive (scroll down to the bottom of this page and click on Archive). I see it once and read it .... if I want to follow it I can either respond or subscribe (with no response), and I'll get and email when the next new post is made.

I wish we could go back to the old way at least for this one item, The repeats drive me crazy

No need to stress out on this ... If you read my post, I have given you a way to resolve the problem

Yes, I have noticed that too, and don't care for it, seems like a time waster to me. Think I prefer the old way although I hadn't been subscribed for very long when they changed over tothis format.

The very easy way to see which threads were created most recently is to use the Archive link at the bottom of every page. In addition to the Archive:

1. Threads are listed in the "regular" indexes exactly the same way they were in the old format. They are in reverse order starting with those with the newest comments.
2. New comments to existing threads have as much value as new threads that don't yet have additional comments. Somebody took the time to read those threads and to add their thoughts. To dismiss them as irrelevant or to assume they will be of no interest is .... well .... it's just not very friendly, respectful or supportive of your fellow members.

I agree that it is very convenient to have a way to first check those threads that we haven't yet seen at all. Unfortunately the "Unread Threads" function and the "View First Unread [Comment]" do not work well when both are activated at the same time. Until the techs can figure out how to force them to function together correctly we will stick with the more important "View First Unread."