In the Finger Lakes of Western NY, we are fortunate to have several great choices.
Lower prices but bare bones - Golden Lane in Himrod (it's a Mennonite shop). Normal pricing is about $5.50 now - but Ada has a sale off of those prices for a week in February.
O'Susannah's in Watkins Glen is nice; kind of small.
My actual LQS I shop at most often is Ivy Thimble, in Victor.
Calico Gals in Fayetteville
Patchwork Plus in Marcellus (used to be in Skaneateles, moved up the road)
Material Rewards in Dansville
Mount Pleasant in York
Big Flats, Ithaca and Hammondsport also have nice shops.
Seriously, the Finger Lakes are a great place to visit. Good wines, too...