Thanks everyone! I now have a plan of action from what you've posted. DH is out all day, so I'm going to tackle making a new cover today--hopefully (we'll see if my little one cooperates). Super excited to have a cover I actually enjoy looking at.
And, I love the idea of the pressing board made out of a wooden TV tray. I'm going to search a couple thrift stores to try to find a TV tray I can use.