Neither! I got tired of fixing the darn thing and took the rollers out of the bathroom completely. I opened a hole in the wall, then re-plastered the wall so they now have a little cuby hole to set the paper rolls in. In the masterbath I have a full built in shelf the holds extra rolls as well as "HIS" magazines. Gosh I hate all that clutter in the bathroom. So I use the main bathroom and he has the mater bathroom to himself. And of course any guess we have coming in have their own bathroom in the old master bedroom.
No rollers here just little cubby holes!!!