I, too, was beginning to wonder why I was so cold at night. Living in Illinois normally we do not have the cold weather that Wisconsin does (I grew up in Wisconsin.) At any rate, I happily put my new dog quilt on my bed a month ago and was very pleased until the past couple of weeks. Now I am freezing to death. Decided this morning to put the puffy JCPenney one back on. I am so glad that someone else is having the same problem. I thought it was just me and my precious "dog quilt". Guess I will just wait until spring to put it back on.
Now I have an excuses to make another one that is warmer.