Kaitlyn, I have similar case damage for a Singer 128 that I received in the mail from shopgoodwill dot com. I plan on repairing it by gently compressing the spool pin "punch" back to the original shape after I put white glue in and between the plywood layers. I will probably have to cut with a band saw the contour of case's exterior into a piece of scrap wood to clamp in place and re-form the case's damaged contour as I re-glue the "punch through." I will then use the techniques described in some of the 'stickies' of this blog to refresh the shellac finish on the case. Good luck with yours!