I have used both W&N and a medium poly bat when hand quilting. The W&N works much better. You have more control if using a hoop. I use a variety of sized hoops when hand quilting. The thinner batting makes it easier to control. I can't answer to other bats. I have done a good number of quilts with hand quilting (including the one as my avatar). The larger the quilt the stronger your arms have to be. That however comes as you quilt. Take your time and enjoy the experience.