Quiltingboard Forums

Quiltingboard Forums (https://www.quiltingboard.com/)
-   For Vintage & Antique Machine Enthusiasts (https://www.quiltingboard.com/vintage-antique-machine-enthusiasts-f22/)
-   -   Are there different 201's????? (https://www.quiltingboard.com/vintage-antique-machine-enthusiasts-f22/there-different-201s-t290247.html)

SusieQOH 08-07-2017 06:18 AM

Are there different 201's?????
 
Mine was made in 1955. When I see the term 201-2 I'm confused.
Can someone un-confuse me? :)
Thanks

NZquilter 08-07-2017 06:44 AM

Sorry, it was probably my PM this morning that confused you! If I understand correctly, the Singer 201-2 has a potted motor and the Singer 201-3, or 201K has a belt driven motor. The Singer 201-1 is a treadle. I think they are kind of rare though (???) Maybe I'm wrong. I also don't think that the year made has anything to do with the model number. (Please some one correct me if I am wrong here. This is the info I found after a quick Google search.)

Just like the Singer 15-88 is a treadle, the Singer 15-90 has a belt driven motor and the Singer 15-91 has a potted motor. I hope I'm not confusing you more!

SusieQOH 08-07-2017 07:09 AM

Oh thank you!!! I couldn't find the info that you were able to find. What I have is a 201-2. It has the potted motor.
And my 15 is a 90.

Mickey2 08-07-2017 07:13 AM

The K only stands for the Kilbowie factory in Scotland. I have discoverd there are several versions and minor differences. For some reason it looksl ike treadle and hand crank were more common for a much longer time in Europe than in the US. I'm not sure why. I keep bumping into hand crank 99s with serial numbers dating them well into the 50s, less so with the 201s, but at least as long as the cast iron production kept up. There are much fewer 201K2s over here, the most common is the belt driven version.

There are two types of chromed plates on these, the later one is pin-striped sort of, and there are at least two different gold decal patterns, maybe three. There are variants to the base of the spool pins too, but doesn't seem to have been given special subnumbers (The part number of the body might differ?)

The black cast iron 201s were taken over by a third version in cast aluminiun at the UK factory, given the number 201K23, and with a new exterior design. My 1955 is an all beige version of this one, but the most common is seems to be a beige-brown color combination. The early aluminium production was all black with chrome details, these turn up but not as often as the beige.

SusieQOH 08-07-2017 09:12 AM

I've never seen a beige 201. Wow!
I've never had a hand crank. I have a hard time imagining being able to sew with it. They are so cute though.

J3General 08-07-2017 10:26 AM

@Mickey2 - my understanding is that hand cranks were more popular in Europe because rooms in homes were smaller on average and a hand crank does not take up as much room as a treadle.

@SusieQOH - I have four hand cranks (1 28K, 2 127's, and 1 128) and find them about as easy as an electric to sew on - just not as fast. In fact, I prefer an 'hc' for precise, slow speed, ss sewing - the stitches on mine are very pretty. I plan on teaching my five young granddaughters to sew on them (and then gifting them one each as well as an electric if they progress in their skills). An 'hc' appears safer than an electric for young fingers!

SusieQOH 08-07-2017 12:51 PM


Originally Posted by J3General (Post 7881779)
@Mickey2 - my understanding is that hand cranks were more popular in Europe because rooms in homes were smaller on average and a hand crank does not take up as much room as a treadle.

@SusieQOH - I have four hand cranks (1 28K, 2 127's, and 1 128) and find them about as easy as an electric to sew on - just not as fast. In fact, I prefer an 'hc' for precise, slow speed, ss sewing - the stitches on mine are very pretty. I plan on teaching my five young granddaughters to sew on them (and then gifting them one each as well as an electric if they progress in their skills). An 'hc' appears safer than an electric for young fingers!

Very interesting!!! Thanks for the lesson- that's one style I knew nothing about.

OurWorkbench 08-07-2017 03:46 PM


Originally Posted by SusieQOH (Post 7881578)
Mine was made in 1955. When I see the term 201-2 I'm confused.
Can someone un-confuse me? :)
Thanks

A good resource can be found at http://ismacs.net/singer_sewing_mach...ny/model-list/

After reading the description on that page you can then go to appropriate page for the model you want to know more about.

Janey - Neat people never make the exciting discoveries I do.

SusieQOH 08-07-2017 03:50 PM

Janey, I forgot to check that one, thanks! I know I've gone there before but forgot about it.

SteveH 08-09-2017 07:16 AM

in regards to sewing with a handcrank...

With an electric machine or treadle most folks use one hand in front, and one hand behind the stitch. You have NO feel for the "pull" that the machine has, that is why folks use the second hand, to gain that control.

With a handcrank each rotation of the handcrank cycles the machine 3 times. You can literally feel in your right hand the feed dogs pulling the fabric through. You only need your left hand to steer and provide some resistance to the pull. You have WAY more precise control of stitch location. I have yet to find a person who does not find hand crank sewing easier than electric or treadle, once they have practiced it a bit.

Mickey2 08-09-2017 07:57 AM

Everything is bigger in America, I'm sure, but a portable electric or hand crank is much the same size. The 201 was one of the top models, it probably wasn't a cost issue for the buyer. Motors and light became much more affordable around 1930 too. I'm guessing a lot of factors played in, and at the time a lot were used to hand cranks and knew what they chose.

I have only test sewed with hand cranks, I did not find it difficult it went a long very nicely, perfectly even seams, but I know there are advantages to holding pieces and seams together with two hands, and control the stitching with a pedal or knee lever. There are a few I know who keep a hand crank for particular jobs, the swear to them (one has a 28, another a 99). Topstitching and buttonholer being two of them.

leonf 08-09-2017 07:59 AM

Whoa, I have a chance to amend SteveH's post. " I'm not worthy" Singer HC's give 3 revolutions per one crank of the handcrank. Many other HCs only turn one revolution per crank so you have even more precise control.

Love my HCs Love teaching with them.

leonf 08-09-2017 08:04 AM

Availability of electricity made a difference, especially in remote rural areas. Handcranks always worked

Mickey2 08-09-2017 08:10 AM

Good point leonf, we have managed to gather a few reasons already :- )

It's not related to the 201, but I have wondered about the older type hand cranks, large heavy weels and the gearing looks different.

This picture is from Sew muse

http://www.sewmuse.co.uk/gritzner%20saxonia.jpg

leonf 08-09-2017 10:35 AM

I haven't checked the ration on mine. Prolly should check it.

https://www.quiltingboard.com/member...653-574918.jpg

SteveH 08-09-2017 02:51 PM

You are correct leonf, I was referring to Singer!

The only ones I know of that do not are the ones with the handle mounted on the Handwheel directly. If you know of units with a handcrank mechanism that is something other than 3:1 please let me know!

SusieQOH 08-09-2017 03:11 PM


Originally Posted by SteveH (Post 7883275)
in regards to sewing with a handcrank...

With an electric machine or treadle most folks use one hand in front, and one hand behind the stitch. You have NO feel for the "pull" that the machine has, that is why folks use the second hand, to gain that control.

With a handcrank each rotation of the handcrank cycles the machine 3 times. You can literally feel in your right hand the feed dogs pulling the fabric through. You only need your left hand to steer and provide some resistance to the pull. You have WAY more precise control of stitch location. I have yet to find a person who does not find hand crank sewing easier than electric or treadle, once they have practiced it a bit.

Thanks for the info!! I've never even seen one. Oh no, don't get me started. I have enough machines :D

SteveH 08-09-2017 03:34 PM

Enough? LOL I have 15 handcranks and 25 treadles set up in an 950 sq ft house.... (all pre 1900 machines, all work)

NZquilter 08-09-2017 06:42 PM


Originally Posted by SteveH (Post 7883580)
Enough? LOL I have 15 handcranks and 25 treadles set up in an 950 sq ft house.... (all pre 1900 machines, all work)

Wow!!! That's all I can say! Good for you for saving them all!

NZquilter 08-09-2017 06:46 PM


Originally Posted by SteveH (Post 7883275)
in regards to sewing with a handcrank...

With an electric machine or treadle most folks use one hand in front, and one hand behind the stitch. You have NO feel for the "pull" that the machine has, that is why folks use the second hand, to gain that control.

With a handcrank each rotation of the handcrank cycles the machine 3 times. You can literally feel in your right hand the feed dogs pulling the fabric through. You only need your left hand to steer and provide some resistance to the pull. You have WAY more precise control of stitch location. I have yet to find a person who does not find hand crank sewing easier than electric or treadle, once they have practiced it a bit.

Thanks for the info. I have often wondered how one would control the fabric with one hand and hand crank with other, and still stitch fast.

Farmhousesewer 08-10-2017 07:43 AM

Thanks the point, you don't stitch fast with a handcrank. Patience, enjoying the process rather than reaching the goal...

:o

Farmhousesewer 08-10-2017 08:04 AM

2 Attachment(s)
I am so excited. We drove over to NC yesterday to pick up a 201-1. Found out the owner's Grandmother from Turkey, but married a man from the USA who was in the CIA. This machine was made in Great Britain. They moved around a lot, in Europe, which would be the reason the cabinet looks the way it does. Top seam cracked and skirt protector broken off. It is a small, newer, enclosed treadle cabinet. Since it is not on the ISMACS list, I imagine it also is a European cabinet model. Even had a mat, but it is as hard as a rock and bent over the far end. Anyone have ideas on salvaging the mat? Sun ?
[ATTACH=CONFIG]578464[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]578465[/ATTACH]
This was one on my Wish list.

Glenn 08-10-2017 08:25 AM

I like the cabinet. Not much you can do with the hard rubber mat. Some say lay it in the sun and it may soften up. PB states on the can it will soften a toilet flapper to make it seal better. You can try this but I really don't know.

Mickey2 08-10-2017 08:39 AM

These treadles turn up here now and then, a few various cabinets, simpler one and two drawer tables. My 201 was probably a treadle ones too, but it was converted to motor and electrics pretty early in it's life I'm not sure. I am on the look for the elusive 201K2, I hope it will turn up locally :- )

Glenn 08-10-2017 09:26 AM

You can also spray with silicone spray place in a black trash bag and leave for a week. Treat again if needed. Take out and wipe dry. You must saturate the thing good before placing in the bag. Now Maria this is what I read on the net so really have not tried it. Good Luck.

SusieQOH 08-10-2017 09:42 AM

That's a beauty! I want a treadle

Farmhousesewer 08-10-2017 04:58 PM

Hmmm interesting. Will let you know if anything works.

purplefiend 08-10-2017 05:37 PM


Originally Posted by NZquilter (Post 7881600)
Sorry, it was probably my PM this morning that confused you! If I understand correctly, the Singer 201-2 has a potted motor and the Singer 201-3, or 201K has a belt driven motor. The Singer 201-1 is a treadle. I think they are kind of rare though (???) Maybe I'm wrong. I also don't think that the year made has anything to do with the model number. (Please some one correct me if I am wrong here. This is the info I found after a quick Google search.)

Just like the Singer 15-88 is a treadle, the Singer 15-90 has a belt driven motor and the Singer 15-91 has a potted motor. I hope I'm not confusing you more!

You forgot the 201K-4 which is a hand crank. I have one that I prefer to use as a treadle.
Sharon in Texas

OurWorkbench 08-12-2017 07:15 AM


Originally Posted by Farmhousesewer (Post 7884113)
...Even had a mat, but it is as hard as a rock and bent over the far end. Anyone have ideas on salvaging the mat? Sun ?

This was one on my Wish list.

Congratulations. Neat machine.

I read something recently about restoring? rubber at http://www.victoriansweatshop.com/po...708?trail=1800 but no confirmations or results. Off I went to research and found a few links about rubber parts on cars, bikes etc., with some rather impressive results. About two thirds down some pictures by drrice using Thor #12 which is 98% wintergreen oil http://forums.sohc4.net/index.php/topic,29707.50.html . Also on this page - http://forums.sohc4.net/index.php/topic,62328.150.html it claims that still good several years later by AshimotoK0 This is a thread that is 7 pages long. Seems like a mat would be helped by this treatment using Thor's #12 tire treatment (main page = http://www.thoroil.com/main.html ). I'm not sure where you could purchase it locally, but seems a less expensive option compared to wintergreen essential oil.

Janey - Neat people never make the exciting discoveries I do.forgot

Farmhousesewer 08-12-2017 08:40 AM

Janey & John,
Thanks for doing some research for me. We just brought the cabinet into the basement yesterday, but ran errands all day and volunteered at the Heritage Center last evening. Left it in the car overnight due to rain. I get wintergreen for about 8 bucks for a tiny bottle,, ordered from the pharmacy. Caution: don't put wintergreen into a dispenser plastic bottle, even those with a metal point/dropper. I learned the hard way. it basically destroyed it!.

Will review all of your research & Update on results.

OurWorkbench 08-13-2017 03:28 AM


Originally Posted by Farmhousesewer (Post 7885356)
Janey & John,
Thanks for doing some research for me. We just brought the cabinet into the basement yesterday, but ran errands all day and volunteered at the Heritage Center last evening. Left it in the car overnight due to rain. I get wintergreen for about 8 bucks for a tiny bottle,, ordered from the pharmacy. Caution: don't put wintergreen into a dispenser plastic bottle, even those with a metal point/dropper. I learned the hard way. it basically destroyed it!.

Will review all of your research & Update on results.

You are welcome. I hope it works.

It does mention using a new metal paint can to put the mixture in. I know essential oils can be a little pricey that is why I mentioned the Thor's #12 tire prep beside that what was shown as being used. I forgot to mention some have had better results by heating the item before putting in the mixture (some have used almost boiling water and other have used xylene/xylol). Another note that I read about is that it will sometimes swell but returns to normal size after drying out a few days.

I'm not sure I got the links absolutely right. I read quite a few pages of using wintergreen oil and water or xylene. I did a little more reading and found http://www.hdmworld.com/tirepreps.htm that has a Thor #12 quart (32 oz) for $19 - don't know what shipping would be, though.

I wish I had some old rubber to test. I work in a sheet metal shop and I know we use xylene to clean gunk off sheet metal, and then I would have to find the wintergreen oil- oh well.

Janey - Neat people never make the exciting discoveries I do.

OurWorkbench 08-13-2017 03:45 AM


Originally Posted by OurWorkbench (Post 7885783)
.... I forgot to mention some have had better results by heating the item before putting in the mixture (some have used almost boiling water and other have used xylene/xylol)....

Note: Do not heat xylene at all!!!!!!

The water mixture is heated to help rubber absorb the oil.

Janey - Neat people never make the exciting discoveries I do.

Farmhousesewer 08-14-2017 04:49 AM

I got a list of performance stores in the area to try to avoid shipping. Volunteering at church today, so it will have to wait.
Cut my finger last night while slicing zucchini. It was the last slice! Tried to stop it for 2 hours, no go, so then went to the ER. Only 3-4 stitches, but it is splinted and wrapped to nearby finger. Could not put more stitches, because it is on the side of nail.
Having trouble typing. Will get back.

Glenn 08-14-2017 06:36 AM

Playing with sewing machines is safer than playing with knives.....

themadpatter 08-14-2017 09:43 PM

That is a beauty! I love that cute little cabinet for the treadle. I have a hand crank 27, and it has more piercing power than my Necchi Supernova Ultra Mark II. I used it to make a new bike seat cover from leather recycled from a leather couch.

Charlie777 12-29-2018 04:22 AM

2 Attachment(s)
Hello, I also found a difference in the heads, my treadle has a riser for the flat spool pin holder/inspection plate and my other has the top shape of the Model 66. I don't know if there are any differences inside.[ATTACH=CONFIG]605936[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]605937[/ATTACH] The treadle is circa 1953 and the other is a centennial 1951.

Cari-in-Oly 12-29-2018 11:33 AM

Hello Charlie777 and welcome. Some 201s have that spool pin plate and some don't. Your 1953 is not a treadle model, a treadled 201 would have the large spoked hand wheel. The smaller solid hand wheel came on the electric machines, and yours being a later 201 it most likely was born an electric machine.

Cari


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:02 AM.