Quilt judging at the local fair
09-27-2009, 08:20 AM
#1
Power Poster
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Front row
Posts: 14,646
I do the quilt entries for our local fair and of course the judges are out of county. They (apology) are very elderly and very set in their quilt ways. No machine quilted quilt will win if there is a decent hand quilt entered. No matter how great the machine quilted quilt is in color, design or workmanship, the hand quilted one will win. It's to the point of the only quilts turned in to the exhibit are not the best. According to the fair supt. unless other people volunteer to judge out of their county quilts, the same judges are all we have. :evil: Please check with your local fair Supt and ask if they need volunteer judges in other counties. It's not hard, the judging criteria is simple and easy to follow.
09-27-2009, 08:24 AM
#2
Moderator
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: North East Lower peninsula of Michigan
Posts: 6,230
I haven't entered in a fair in a very long time because you are right the judges are very set in their ways, I did it mostly when I taught 4H and didn't enter my own things. Thankfully the girls (ages 8-10) learned to tat and all got blue ribbons, that is a dying art and the judges were impressed. (as was I)
09-27-2009, 09:31 AM
#5
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Sleepy Hollow, NY
Posts: 4,727
the sad thing is the older generation wonders why this is a dying art and it appears to be that the older generation isn't open to new ideas and technologies.
instead of embracing the new generation of quilt artists they choose to discourage any future efforts they might make.
instead of embracing the new generation of quilt artists they choose to discourage any future efforts they might make.
09-27-2009, 09:53 AM
#6
Super Member
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 4,688
Originally Posted by kluedesigns
the sad thing is the older generation wonders why this is a dying art and it appears to be that the older generation isn't open to new ideas and technologies.
instead of embracing the new generation of quilt artists they choose to discourage any future efforts they might make.
instead of embracing the new generation of quilt artists they choose to discourage any future efforts they might make.
09-27-2009, 10:07 AM
#7
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Sleepy Hollow, NY
Posts: 4,727
i was making a statement in regards to the few situtations that have been posted above my post.
it is not a reflection on you or your area or your age.
"The audence and judging on most levels beyond local, are much more accepting of current and forward thinking techniques and designs, regardless of their age."
this statement from you isn't even accurate because are local level is extremely open to new technologies and ideas.
it is not a reflection on you or your area or your age.
"The audence and judging on most levels beyond local, are much more accepting of current and forward thinking techniques and designs, regardless of their age."
this statement from you isn't even accurate because are local level is extremely open to new technologies and ideas.
09-27-2009, 01:20 PM
#8
Member
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: midcoast Maine
Posts: 33
Klue
I am one of those older ladies. I beg to differ with you. Stereotyping the older generation as resisting change is a little insulting. Sure there are some who are set in their ways, as are the prejudices of the younger against them, but at my local fair, the judge was NOT old.
Those who won a prize were some of this and some of that. Sheesh I know some of the older generation who love New York Beauty quilts and have made a few of them, using the newer batiks. I know some who are eager to try something new and bored with traditional quilts. Those who prefer traditional quilts, do so because that is their taste. So what? They are not an enemy and the wisdom and experience they bring to quilting is priceless if you take the time to listen. Don't forget also, the elderly , many of whom are women who quilt, are on a fixed income. It may be the very least, since women of their age did not go out and get a job, but stayed at home to raise the children because that was the custom of the day in which they lived. That means they may not have hundreds of dollars to spend on having every quilt they make quilted by a person who will do it for them. They may not have the bucks to spend on ten dollar a yard fabric to make a quilt, then add the hundred or more to have it quilted by machine. They prefer the camaradie and the social contacts of hand quilting with others. Old age can get very lonely, especially if one loses their spouse along the way and ones children are far far away.
So, your comment is especially insulting, as far as I am concerned.
I am one of those older ladies. I beg to differ with you. Stereotyping the older generation as resisting change is a little insulting. Sure there are some who are set in their ways, as are the prejudices of the younger against them, but at my local fair, the judge was NOT old.
Those who won a prize were some of this and some of that. Sheesh I know some of the older generation who love New York Beauty quilts and have made a few of them, using the newer batiks. I know some who are eager to try something new and bored with traditional quilts. Those who prefer traditional quilts, do so because that is their taste. So what? They are not an enemy and the wisdom and experience they bring to quilting is priceless if you take the time to listen. Don't forget also, the elderly , many of whom are women who quilt, are on a fixed income. It may be the very least, since women of their age did not go out and get a job, but stayed at home to raise the children because that was the custom of the day in which they lived. That means they may not have hundreds of dollars to spend on having every quilt they make quilted by a person who will do it for them. They may not have the bucks to spend on ten dollar a yard fabric to make a quilt, then add the hundred or more to have it quilted by machine. They prefer the camaradie and the social contacts of hand quilting with others. Old age can get very lonely, especially if one loses their spouse along the way and ones children are far far away.
So, your comment is especially insulting, as far as I am concerned.
09-27-2009, 06:45 PM
#10
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Mount Vernon, Oh
Posts: 698
Originally Posted by Maryann
Klue
I am one of those older ladies. I beg to differ with you. Stereotyping the older generation as resisting change is a little insulting. Sure there are some who are set in their ways, as are the prejudices of the younger against them, but at my local fair, the judge was NOT old.
Those who won a prize were some of this and some of that. Sheesh I know some of the older generation who love New York Beauty quilts and have made a few of them, using the newer batiks. I know some who are eager to try something new and bored with traditional quilts. Those who prefer traditional quilts, do so because that is their taste. So what? They are not an enemy and the wisdom and experience they bring to quilting is priceless if you take the time to listen. Don't forget also, the elderly , many of whom are women who quilt, are on a fixed income. It may be the very least, since women of their age did not go out and get a job, but stayed at home to raise the children because that was the custom of the day in which they lived. That means they may not have hundreds of dollars to spend on having every quilt they make quilted by a person who will do it for them. They may not have the bucks to spend on ten dollar a yard fabric to make a quilt, then add the hundred or more to have it quilted by machine. They prefer the camaradie and the social contacts of hand quilting with others. Old age can get very lonely, especially if one loses their spouse along the way and ones children are far far away.
So, your comment is especially insulting, as far as I am concerned.
I am one of those older ladies. I beg to differ with you. Stereotyping the older generation as resisting change is a little insulting. Sure there are some who are set in their ways, as are the prejudices of the younger against them, but at my local fair, the judge was NOT old.
Those who won a prize were some of this and some of that. Sheesh I know some of the older generation who love New York Beauty quilts and have made a few of them, using the newer batiks. I know some who are eager to try something new and bored with traditional quilts. Those who prefer traditional quilts, do so because that is their taste. So what? They are not an enemy and the wisdom and experience they bring to quilting is priceless if you take the time to listen. Don't forget also, the elderly , many of whom are women who quilt, are on a fixed income. It may be the very least, since women of their age did not go out and get a job, but stayed at home to raise the children because that was the custom of the day in which they lived. That means they may not have hundreds of dollars to spend on having every quilt they make quilted by a person who will do it for them. They may not have the bucks to spend on ten dollar a yard fabric to make a quilt, then add the hundred or more to have it quilted by machine. They prefer the camaradie and the social contacts of hand quilting with others. Old age can get very lonely, especially if one loses their spouse along the way and ones children are far far away.
So, your comment is especially insulting, as far as I am concerned.
We are not all stogy old people, I enjoy seeing quilts here, modern and traditional. We all have our likes, and I am sorry if someone made you feel unworthy by their criticisms, as they shouldn't have.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
