Even if it was muddy....
and it is not... why say any thing???
Sorry don't under stand

or are you saying because she does not like the fabric she won't quilt it for you????

i agree, not muddy at all

Makes me think of fall! I love the colors!

I love the Civil War fabrics!! Enjoy the "softer" colors while I'm doing my Dear Jane. Really like your quilt!

The only that matters is if it matches the decor of the room and/or the dish set of the table it will be used on. Couldn't see it in a contemporary room or a French traditional, etc. In the right setting it should be lovely. Why would she judge it outside of the setting that it will be used? It looks as if the workmanship is fine. What more could she judge? I think her judgment is skewed.

It doesn't look muddy to me. I think it's beautiful.

I think that it is very pretty, love civil war fabrics!

Muddy? Uh, no. Beautiful? Yes! I don't know what your LQS was smoking but it's not muddy & it is beautiful. I love Civil War fabrics & this is perfect!

It's a gorgeous quilt! Nice job! :)