I vote for the star. Great looking blocks!:thumbup:

I understand your dilemma! They all look great. My favorites are the top right, bottom left and bottom middle.

Barn Raising is my favorite log cabin layout.

I like 1st row left , And 2nd row left the best

I like number 5.

Top right, bottom left are my favorites.

go with what you like
but I vote 2 nd row # 1 or 2

Barn raising is always my fallback as I just love it.

Have you considered letting your father decide? He may have a clear idea of which one he likes best. If he is far away, just print the page, even Black and white is okay, it will give him the idea.

Agreed, those are the three I like as well. I wish I knew the names of all the layouts.