Quilt Judging
08-05-2019, 10:20 AM
#21
Member
Join Date: Jul 2015
Location: Northern California
Posts: 75
I get discouraged when I see so many custom quilted quilts in shows. I'm a hand quilter and have begun to feel that we are no longer appreciated. It also bugs me because it seems like a betrayal of quilting's origins. Nowadays you're made to feel like you can't compete if you don't have a $10,000 machine. Considering that not that long ago quilting was about necessity and making do, we may have gone too far in the other direction.
My mother had an acquaintance who sent her pieced top to a quilter in another state. Then she had the gall to enter it in our local show as her work. My mother was appalled and told her so.
My mother had an acquaintance who sent her pieced top to a quilter in another state. Then she had the gall to enter it in our local show as her work. My mother was appalled and told her so.
08-05-2019, 10:39 AM
#22
Super Member
Join Date: Oct 2015
Location: Va.
Posts: 5,753
If you check out the larger shows, you will see that there are separate categories for hand quilting, long arm quilting and domestic machine quilting. You certainly don’t need an expensive machine to win awards at those shows. One of my quilts has won awards at 3 different shows and it was quilted on my domestic PQ1500s that I bought used for $350.
Rob
Rob
08-05-2019, 11:12 AM
#23
Super Member
Join Date: Dec 2015
Location: Ontario, Canada
Posts: 4,353
I was pleased this year to see in our local quilt show prize book that it said that all quilts must be pieced and quilted by the competitor!
It also stated that quilts will be judged on "Uniqueness and creativity", so at least people know what they are up against. The quilts are not going to be judged by normal "quilt show" rules, obviously.
I enter my quilts because I enjoy seeing them hanging and I want to support the local fair as there are fewer and fewer entries each year. I don't expect to win and it's a bonus and makes me smile if I get a ribbon.
Watson
It also stated that quilts will be judged on "Uniqueness and creativity", so at least people know what they are up against. The quilts are not going to be judged by normal "quilt show" rules, obviously.
I enter my quilts because I enjoy seeing them hanging and I want to support the local fair as there are fewer and fewer entries each year. I don't expect to win and it's a bonus and makes me smile if I get a ribbon.
Watson
08-06-2019, 09:43 AM
#24
Super Member
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Carmichael, CA
Posts: 1,971
Originally Posted by feline fanatic
I encourage you to look up the award winning quilts by Janet Stone and Sherry Reynolds (just google images of Janet Stone quilts or Sherry Reynolds quilts). Make sure you have a basket handy for your jaw, because it will drop. Both of these extremely talented ladies do all their own quilting on domestic machines. I have been fortunate to see at least 4 of Janet's quilts in person and I have seen Sherry's most recent quilt Eternal Beauty. The workmanship is amazing. Also all of Janet's applique is raw edge fusible stitched down with a blanket stitch. She has taken numerous AQS BOS awards with her charming quilts.
Also look at the work by Diane Gaudynski another phenomenal DSM quilter.
It is possible to do this kind of quilting on a DSM. I never enjoyed the process of sitdown quilting but boy do I love standup quilting on a rack. I am in awe of people who can do that kind of work on a domestic and I strongly feel some of their tiny little fills would be hard to replicate in the same scale with a LA. I can do some tiny stuff with mine but not like they can!
Also look at the work by Diane Gaudynski another phenomenal DSM quilter.
It is possible to do this kind of quilting on a DSM. I never enjoyed the process of sitdown quilting but boy do I love standup quilting on a rack. I am in awe of people who can do that kind of work on a domestic and I strongly feel some of their tiny little fills would be hard to replicate in the same scale with a LA. I can do some tiny stuff with mine but not like they can!
08-06-2019, 11:12 AM
#25
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2013
Location: Dallas, TX
Posts: 677
Well in my opinion there are cuddle quilts, bed quilts, wall art. I love that there is so much variety.
As for shows if you don't like the rules maybe volunteer and help the rules evolve. My guild show is this weekend. There are several divisions of the quilts. There are categories for one-person quilt which is one person doing all the piecing, quilting and then there are two-person quilts. There are artisan or master entries so if you have been a previous winner or been paid for your work then you are automatically competing in the master division. There is also a category for first time entry. There are awards for merit hand quilting, and merit machine quilting. there is a category for digitized (embroidery) designs. So probably most of these divisions and categories came about because people discussed the issues and made decisions.
One last point... I love to see the quilts hanging. This is something so inspiring and fun. I like seeing one of mine hanging. I love that the guild show promotes our art.
As for shows if you don't like the rules maybe volunteer and help the rules evolve. My guild show is this weekend. There are several divisions of the quilts. There are categories for one-person quilt which is one person doing all the piecing, quilting and then there are two-person quilts. There are artisan or master entries so if you have been a previous winner or been paid for your work then you are automatically competing in the master division. There is also a category for first time entry. There are awards for merit hand quilting, and merit machine quilting. there is a category for digitized (embroidery) designs. So probably most of these divisions and categories came about because people discussed the issues and made decisions.
One last point... I love to see the quilts hanging. This is something so inspiring and fun. I like seeing one of mine hanging. I love that the guild show promotes our art.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
