Scrappy is tough for me, too! I still LOVE quilts with lots of color, your is nice, but I, too would rather have one that truly looked like it was woven. The beautiful pattern is lost to the randomness of the fabrics.
That being said I am starting a scrappy d9p this morning, not for me, so let HER decide what to do with it, WHahAHAHA (That is manical laughter).