Thread: American Idol
View Single Post
Old 05-19-2010, 04:16 PM
  #24  
quiltluvr
Super Member
 
quiltluvr's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Lost in a quilt shop :-)
Posts: 1,342
Default

If voting were based solely on performances of last night, Lee edged it out IMHO.

Casey failed to deliver on the first song--except for the guitar which was excellent, 2nd song was sweet and good but now the "judges" are looking for that BIG vocal moment/performance. It's a shame that the judges pick didn't take their own criticism into account when it came to choosing that song. Go figure.

Crystal just didn't hit it. 1st song was lousy, 2nd was 'OK' but much too short to deliver the full impact of that song.

Lee did a decent good job with the 1st song. Sounded good. 2nd song, I'll say is just getting old on the show. That makes twice now this season (Tim Urban sang it previously.) Jason Castro sang it too and left his mark on it was it last season or two seasons ago.

Just seems Lee has the more radio sounding voice. Even tho' America votes the producers have the ultimate say and that's who I think they will make sure wins.

I think Casey goes tonight too.
quiltluvr is offline