Thanks so much for the input everyone - it really helps! I've decided on layout # 2 - it seems more orgainzed-looking and balanced to me (although I really did like the play of the orange against the star in the the other layout.) I am splitting my time between it and the next project ( I am sooo bad - I just couldn't wait!) so it'll be a while before I get the top completely done, and longer if these storms don't let up soon!
The delay couldn't possibly be because orange is my least favorite color, right? LOL