I thnk it is beautiful! You did a wonderful job on it, and should be proud of it, no matter what he thought! Just a question....how old is your dad? I know mine is older, and isn't the best at showing appreciation for things. I wonder if it might be the same in your case? Here's what mine did when I called him today. He will be 82 in October, and when I called and tried to talk to him to wish him a Happy Father's Day, he told me I needed to switch brands of toilet paper that I use! I got a laugh from it, but his comments didn't always make me laugh! I'm sorry he hurt your feelings, and hope he isn't always that way with you!