Thank you all for your wonderful affirmations! I was feeling kind of like the 'bad quilter of the year' until I finally figured it out. The main requirement for the second design was that it had to use the squares I had already cut for the Turning Twenty, because I didn't have a lot of the different cherry fabrics to use.
The design is called "Newport Beach", found in a Judy Martin book named 'Scraps'. It's the quilt on the cover, in the top right corner. Instead of going with a true shadow design, I used what I had - the solid red. Here's the link in case anyone is interested.
http://www.amazon.com/Scraps-Judy-Ma...0776935&sr=8-1