I've always used the Quilt-in-a-day method for log cabins and have made dozens over the years. I think the trick is to add one light and one dark, then square all your blocks to the same size as you go along. I always found it a very forgiving pattern, allowing you to fudge things in, rather than rip out and re-sew.
I am not a fan of paper piecing - Love the look, but if I wanted that kind of aggravation, I would have stayed with my ex!