Thanks for the ideas. :) Looks like I need to make a trip to a dollar store. I was just looking at pie plates and there's a really pretty red fluted one at Amazon for under $10. I have a recipe for apple pie filling that I want to make. I could put a jar of filling in the plate, a pie cutter, a tea towel, pot holders, crust mix, etc.
I'm also thinking those cookies where you put a dollop of jam in the center and use my own jam.